Matter of Edscott Realty Corp. v Town of Lake George PlanningBd.
2015 NY Slip Op 09160 [134 AD3d 1288]
December 10, 2015
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 11, 2015


[*1]
 In the Matter of Edscott Realty Corp., Appellant, vTown of Lake George Planning Board, Respondent, and Charles LaPlante et al.,Respondents.

Bartlett, Pontiff, Stewart & Rhodes, PC, Glens Falls (John D. Wright ofcounsel), for appellant.

Caffry & Flower, Glens Falls (John W. Caffry of counsel), for Charles LaPlanteand another, respondents.

Egan Jr., J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Krogmann, J.), enteredJune 16, 2014 in Warren County, which dismissed petitioner's application, in aproceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, to review a determination of respondent Townof Lake George Planning Board granting conditional site plan approval to respondentsCharles LaPlante and Veronika LaPlante.

Petitioner is the owner of certain real property located along the western shore ofLake George in the Town of Lake George, Warren County, upon which petitioneroperates the Olympian Village Motel. Respondents Charles LaPlante and VeronikaLaPlante own an adjacent parcel of land to the north of petitioner's property upon whichthey operate a motel known as the Stepping Stones Resort. The properties in question areseparated by a stockade fence—the existence and height of which has been thesubject of prior litigation. Insofar as is relevant here, the LaPlantes applied for and weregranted an area variance by the Town of Lake George Zoning Board of Appeals(hereinafter ZBA) to make certain modifications relative to the height of the existingfence, which extends approximately 534 feet from the shoreline of Lake George to State[*2]Route 9N. Supreme Court subsequently upheld theZBA's issuance of the subject variance, but remitted the matter for consideration andapplication of Code of the Town of Lake George § 175-23, whichestablishes a Shoreline Overlay District and addresses, among other things, the screeningrequirements for all structures located within 300 feet of the mean high-water mark ofLake George. Upon remittal, the ZBA concluded that application of the cited ordinancewas a matter for respondent Town of Lake George Planning Board to resolve.

The LaPlantes then applied for site plan review—setting forth the existingnumber of trees along the fence line and describing the vegetation already in place. ThePlanning Board—after expressly referencing the number of trees "up through thefence line"—conditionally approved the LaPlantes' application,[FN*] prompting petitioner tocommence this CPLR article 78 proceeding to challenge the Planning Board'sdetermination. Supreme Court dismissed petitioner's application and, in so doing,rejected petitioner's interpretation of the screening requirements and found that thePlanning Board's determination was in all respects rational. This appeal by petitionerensued.

Code of the Town of Lake George § 175-23 (D) (3) provides that "[a]llstructures, including accessory structures, except docks and boathouses that are within300 feet of the mean high-water mark of Lake George shall be screened by vegetation orlandscaped in such a way so that the view of the structures from the water is filtered andthe visual impact minimized. This screening will be of a buffer type B as described in thelandscape and screening provisions of the commercial design guidelines, unlessotherwise prescribed by the Planning Board. The intent of these regulations is to providea filtered view to promote a see-out-not-in policy." A type B buffer, in turn, requires aminimum landscaped width of 20 feet with three trees (at least six feet in height) per 100linear feet of buffer (see Code of Town of Lake George § 175,Appendix I, § 8.2.8.2, table 3).

Petitioner initially argues that interpretation of the cited ordinance presents a purelylegal question to which no deference to the Planning Board's interpretation is requiredand, as the Planning Board granted conditional site plan approval without requiring theinstallation of any screening on the south side of the subject fence, its determination inthis regard necessarily was arbitrary and capricious. We disagree. Although the ordinanceindeed requires that the view of the fence from the water be "filtered," contrary topetitioner's assertion, "filtered" is not the functional equivalent of "invisible." Similarly,the directive that the visual impact of the fence be minimized does not require that it beeliminated altogether. Further, nothing on the face of Code of the Town of Lake George§ 175-23 (D) (3) or the accompanying design guidelines mandates that thescreening requirements embodied therein be applied to both sides of the fence. Rather, itis apparent that the relevant inquiry is whether—taken as a whole—theview of the fence from the water has been sufficiently filtered and the visual impactthereof has been adequately minimized. This, in turn, is precisely the type of subjective,fact-based determination to which we accord the Planning Board's findings "greatdeference" (Matter of ErinEstates, Inc. v McCracken, 84 AD3d 1487, 1489 [2011] [internal quotationmarks and citation omitted]; see Matter of New York Botanical Garden v Board ofStds. & Appeals of City of N.Y., 91 NY2d 413, 420-421 [1998]).

Here, in addition to the documentation contained in the LaPlantes' site planapplication, [*3]which included a summary of the areavariance previously granted, a description of the existing trees and vegetation along thefence line and various maps, drawings, surveys and photographs of the LaPlantes'property, the Planning Board considered the arguments made by counsel for therespective parties, as well as the observations made by one of its members, whopersonally visited the site and made specific reference to the number of trees along thefence line. In light of these submissions and findings, the record as a whole provides arational basis for the Planning Board's determination. Notably, the plain language ofCode of the Town of Lake George § 175-23 (D) (3) affords the PlanningBoard some measure of discretion relative to the subject screening requirements, and it isnot the role of the courts to second-guess reasoned administrative determinations thatotherwise find support in the record (see Matter of Schaller v Town of New Paltz Zoning Bd. ofAppeals, 108 AD3d 821, 823 [2013]; Matter of Frigault v Town of Richfield Planning Bd., 107 AD3d1347, 1350 [2013]; Matterof Druyan v Village Bd. of Trustees of the Vil. of Cayuga Hgts., 96 AD3d 1207,1208 [2012]).

To the extent that petitioner's challenge to the type and height of the fence itself fallswithin the scope of the Planning Board's grant of conditional site plan approval, we againdiscern no basis upon which to disturb the Planning Board's determination. The purposeof site plan review "is to allow the proper integration into the community" of varioususes and structures—specifically with respect to the impact of such uses andstructures upon the "surrounding properties," as well as "the natural, historic and scenicresources" of the community (Code of Town of Lake George § 175-36 [B],[C]). To that end, the zoning provisions require that the size, shape, color and material ofthe structure at issue—here, the stockade fence—"be consistent with thecharacter of neighboring buildings" and "in harmony with the landscape character" (Codeof Town of Lake George § 175-43 [F] [3], [4]). Here, in light of thestaggered height of the fence, the positioning of its "good side" and the Planning Board'smodification relative to the portion of the fence closest to the lake, together with therecord evidence documenting the existence of similar fences in the immediate vicinity ofpetitioner's property, we agree with Supreme Court that the Planning Board's grant ofconditional site plan approval was not arbitrary and capricious. Petitioner's remainingcontentions, as well as the LaPlantes' request for costs under 22 NYCRR 130-1.1 (a),have been examined and found to be lacking in merit.

Lahtinen, J.P., Garry and Clark, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgment is affirmed,with costs.

Footnotes


Footnote *:Such approval wassubject to a requirement that the portion of the fence that extends onto the LaPlantes'dock be replaced with a less visually obstructive railing.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.