Matter of Toronto Dominion Holdings (U.S.A.), Inc. v Tax AppealsTrib. of the State of N.Y.
2018 NY Slip Op 04402 [162 AD3d 1255]
June 14, 2018
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 1, 2018


[*1]
 In the Matter of Toronto Dominion Holdings (U.S.A.), Inc.,Successor-in-Interest to TD Holdings II, Inc., Petitioner,
v
Tax Appeals Tribunal of theState of New York et al., Respondents.

McDermott Will & Emery, New York City (Alysse B. McLoughlin of counsel), forpetitioner.

Barbara D. Underwood, Attorney General, Albany (Brian D. Ginsberg of counsel), forCommissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.

Egan Jr., J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant to TaxLaw § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunalsustaining a notice of deficiency imposed under Tax Law article 32.

TD Holdings II, Inc. was a banking corporation formed under the laws of Delaware with itsprincipal place of business in New York City.[FN1] Pursuant to Tax Law former article32,[FN2] petitioner wassubject to the banking [*2]corporation franchise tax and, asrelevant here, timely filed banking corporation franchise tax returns for 2005, 2006 and2007.[FN3] Following anaudit of petitioner's franchise tax returns for the subject years, the Department of Taxation andFinance determined that petitioner had miscalculated its franchise tax liabilities for 2006 and2007 and issued petitioner a notice of deficiency, finding that petitioner owed, among otherthings, an additional banking franchise tax amount of $241,444. Petitioner thereafter filed apetition for redetermination with the Division of Tax Appeals. The parties waived a hearing,stipulated to the facts and exhibits and submitted the matter for determination. TheAdministrative Law Judge (hereinafter ALJ) granted petitioner's request to revise the notice ofdeficiency, determining that petitioner was not required to claim any of its 2005 net operatingloss (hereinafter NOL) deduction to reduce its entire net income (hereinafter ENI) for 2006because the banking corporation franchise tax due and owing for that year was not measuredbased upon its ENI and, instead, was calculated using an alternative tax base (see TaxLaw former § 1453 [k-1]).[FN4] The Department then filed an exception withrespondent Tax Appeals Tribunal seeking review of the ALJ's determination. Following oralargument, the Tribunal granted the Department's exception, reversed the ALJ's determination andsustained the notice of deficiency in its entirety, finding that the Department's interpretation ofTax Law former § 1453 (k-1) was reasonable and that petitioner failed to meet itsburden of establishing its entitlement to the claimed NOL deduction. Petitioner then commencedthis CPLR article 78 proceeding, pursuant to Tax Law § 2016, seeking to, amongother things, annul the Tribunal's determination.

Petitioner contends that the Tribunal erred when it required petitioner to claim a portion of its2005 New York NOL deduction in 2006, arguing, in essence, that the presumptively requireddeduction provided for in Tax Law former § 1453 (k-1) was rebutted by the factthat petitioner's franchise tax liability for 2006 was not measured based upon its ENI and,instead, was measured using an alternative tax base. We disagree. As the entity seeking thebenefit of the tax deduction, it was petitioner's burden to establish its entitlement to same (seeMatter of Royal Indem. Co. v Tax Appeals Trib., 75 NY2d 75, 78 [1989]; Matter ofGrace v New York State Tax Commn., 37 NY2d 193, 195 [1975]; Matter of Ayoub v Tax Appeals Trib. of theState of N.Y., 129 AD3d 1354, 1358 [2015]; Matter of Scholastic Bus Serv. v StateTax Commn., 116 [*3]AD2d 915, 916-917 [1986]). Notably,where, as here, a statute authorizes a particular tax deduction, the statute is to be strictlyconstrued against the taxpayer (seeMatter of 677 New Loudon Corp. v State of N.Y. Tax Appeals Trib., 19 NY3d 1058,1060 [2012], cert denied 571 US 952 [2013]; Matter of Grace v New York State TaxCommn., 37 NY2d at 196). Further, as the Department is the agency charged withadministering the statute, its interpretation "must be upheld absent demonstrated irrationality orunreasonableness" (Matter of IslandWaste Servs., Ltd. v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 77 AD3d 1080, 1082[2010], lv denied 16 NY3d 712 [2011]; see Matter of HDV Manhattan, LLC v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State ofN.Y., 156 AD3d 963, 965 [2017]; Matter of Exxon Mobil Corp. v State of N.Y. Tax Appeals Trib., 126AD3d 1059, 1060 [2015], lv denied 25 NY3d 912 [2015]). This Court's scope ofreview is limited; so long as the Tribunal's determination is rationally based and is supported bysubstantial evidence, it must be confirmed, even if a different conclusion would not have beenunreasonable (see Matter of American Tel. & Tel. Co. v State Tax Commn., 61NY2d 393, 400 [1984]; Matter of Jay'sDistribs., Inc. v Boone, 148 AD3d 1237, 1237 [2017], lv denied 29 NY3d 918[2017]; Matter of CS Integrated, LLC vTax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 19 AD3d 886, 889 [2005]).

As relevant here, prior to its repeal, Tax Law former article 32, imposed a franchise tax onbanking corporations for the privilege of exercising its franchise or doing business in New York(see Tax Law former § 1451 [a]). Computation of the franchise tax wasbased upon either a percentage of a banking corporation's ENI, its taxable assets, its alternativeentire net income or a fixed dollar amount, whichever base resulted in imposition of the highesttax (see Tax Law former § 1455 [a], [b] [1]-[3]). For purposes of computingENI, a banking corporation was allowed a deduction for its NOLs, which, with the exception offour statutory exceptions not applicable here, "shall be presumably the same as the [federal NOL]deduction allowed under [Internal Revenue Code (26 USC) § 172]" (Tax Lawformer § 1453 [k-1]).

The facts of this matter are not in dispute. In 2005, for New York banking corporationfranchise tax purposes, petitioner incurred a net operating loss of $9,259,151. In 2006, petitionerelected not to carry over and claim any of its 2005 New York NOL deduction to reduce its ENI,concluding that it was not necessary to do so because its franchise tax liability for that year wascalculated using an alternative tax base (i.e., its taxable assets), not its ENI. Thus, petitionercarried forward the entirety of its 2005 New York NOL deduction, claiming it on its 2007 NewYork franchise tax return. Following an audit, the notice of deficiency subsequently issued topetitioner represented, among other things, the additional franchise tax that petitioner would haveowed had it deducted its 2005 New York NOL for the presumptively required amount in 2006(i.e., $3,767,459).[FN5] Thequestion to be resolved by this Court, therefore, is whether the Tribunal's determinationinterpreting Tax Law former § 1453 (k-1) as requiring petitioner to use its 2005New York NOL deduction to decrease its 2006 ENI by the presumptively required deduction(see Tax Law former § 1453 [k-1]) was irrational, despite the fact that itsfranchise tax liability for that year was calculated based upon an alternative tax basis.

We are unpersuaded by petitioner's contention that the Tribunal's determination [*4]constituted an error of law or was otherwise irrational. Notably, TaxLaw former § 1453 (k-1) was statutorily coupled with the federal ordering rules setforth in Internal Revenue Code (26 USC) § 172, which specifically provided that"[t]he entire amount of the [NOL] for any taxable year . . . shall be carried to theearliest of the taxable years to which . . . such loss may be carried" (InternalRevenue Code [26 USC] § 172 [b] [2]). Thus, for banking corporation franchise taxpurposes, application of this federal ordering rule was not a mere attempt by the Department toachieve "mechanical conformity with federal tax principles"; it was statutorily required and, assuch, said presumption served as the "starting point" for determining the amount of NOL thatmust be used to offset a taxpayer's ENI (see Matter of Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co. v TaxAppeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 214 AD2d 238, 241 [1995], lv denied 87 NY2d 811[1996]; Matter of Eveready Ins. Co. v New York State Tax Commn., 129 AD2d 958,959-960 [1987], lv denied 70 NY2d 604 [1987]; Matter of Telmar CommunicationsCorp. v Procaccino, 48 AD2d 189, 191 [1975]).

Petitioner contends that the Tribunal must disregard this federal ordering rule where, as here,a taxpayer does not derive a tax benefit from the application thereof. However, the fact that ataxpayer may not reap a franchise tax benefit in a given year is not determinative of the issue, solong as such a result is not inconsistent with the application of the statute (see Matter ofRoyal Indem. Co. v Tax Appeals Trib., 75 NY2d at 78; Matter of Grace v New YorkState Tax Commn., 37 NY2d at 196; Matter of American Employers' Ins. Co. v State TaxCommn., 114 AD2d 736, 738 [1985]), and it remains petitioner's burden "to establish thatany deduction claimed on its return is clearly provided for by statute" (Matter of AmericanEmployers' Ins. Co. v State Tax Commn., 114 AD2d at 738). Here, there is nothing in thelanguage of Tax Law former § 1453 (k-1), and petitioner has not cited to any otherstatutory authority, that provides a banking corporation with the option to deduct none of itsavailable New York NOL carryover deduction in subsequent years where it posts a positive ENI,solely because its franchise tax liability for that year is calculated using an alternative tax base(see Tax Law former § 1453 [k-1]; see generally Matter of Grace v NewYork State Tax Commn., 37 NY2d at 197).[FN6]

The Tribunal's determination in Matter of Brooke-Bond Group (U.S.) Inc. (1995 WL774860, 1995 NY Tax LEXIS 659 [NY St Div of Tax Appeals DTA No. 810951, Dec. 28,1995]), meanwhile, does not mandate a different result. Matter of Brooke-Bond did notdetermine whether the presumptively required deduction provided for in Tax Law former§ 1453 (k-1) is effectively rebutted where, as here, a banking corporation's franchisetax liability for a given year is calculated using an alternative tax base. Rather, Matter ofBrooke-Bond determined that, in an instance where claiming a New York NOL deductionwould result in a banking corporation having a negative ENI for a given year, the taxpayer onlyhad to claim that portion of its available New York NOL deduction necessary to reduce its ENI tozero. This holding was based on the federal rule that NOL deductions were limited to the amountnecessary to bring a taxpayer's taxable income to zero (see Internal Revenue Code [26USC] § 172 [b] [2] [B]), which, by application thereof, effectively served to rebutthe presumption that a taxpayer's New York NOL must be the same as its federal NOL. UnlikeMatter of Brooke-Bond, there is no analogous federal rule of conformity or ordering rulethat tethers the use of an available New [*5]York NOL deductionto a taxpayer's payment of franchise tax on an alternative tax basis.[FN7] Nor do we find that any of the various policyconsiderations set forth by petitioner otherwise sustained its burden of proving its entitlement tosuch a deduction.

The Tribunal's determination, therefore, is consistent with the statute and it was notirrational, and petitioner has otherwise failed to establish that its interpretation of the statute "isthe only logical construction of the statutory language" (see Matter of Aetna Cas. & Sur.Co. v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 214 AD2d at 241). Accordingly, giving deferenceto the Tribunal and its statutory interpretation of Tax Law former § 1453, we findthat its determination requiring petitioner to claim a portion of its 2005 New York NOLdeduction equal to its federal NOL deduction in the 2006 tax year to be reasonable and supportedby substantial evidence in the record (see Matter of Royal Indem. Co. v Tax AppealsTrib., 75 NY2d at 78; Matter of Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co. v Tax Appeals Trib. of Stateof N.Y., 214 AD2d at 241; Matter of Eveready Ins. Co. v New York State TaxCommn., 129 AD2d at 959; Matter of Telmar Communications Corp. v Procaccino,48 AD2d at 191). To the extent not specifically addressed, petitioner's remaining contentionshave been reviewed and found to be unavailing.

Garry, P.J., Clark, Mulvey and Rumsey, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:In 2016, prior to thecommencement of this proceeding, TD Holdings II, Inc. was liquidated into Toronto DominionHoldings (U.S.A.), Inc. For purposes of this proceeding, all references to petitioner will refer toboth entities.

Footnote 2:Tax Law article 32 was repealedby Laws of 2014 (ch 59, § 1), effective January 1, 2015. Its provisions, however,remain in full force and effect with respect to taxable tax years prior to January 1, 2015 and,therefore, were controlling at all times relevant to this proceeding.

Footnote 3:For federal income tax purposes,petitioner and its subsidiaries were included as part of a consolidated federal tax return with alarger group of corporate entities. Thus, in order to calculate petitioner's New York bankingcorporation franchise tax liability for 2005, 2006 and 2007, petitioner prepared pro forma federalincome tax returns, reflecting the income and deductions that petitioner and its subsidiarieswould have reported had they each filed their own consolidated federal income tax returns.

Footnote 4:The ALJ did sustain the notice ofdeficiency, in part, to the extent that it found petitioner's 2007 New York NOL deduction wasrequired to be capped at $7,979,587, as opposed to the $9,259,151 claimed, to ensure that itsNew York NOL deduction did not exceed its federal NOL deduction for the same year(see Tax Law former § 1453 [k-1] [3]).

Footnote 5:Although petitioner's choice notto carry forward and claim its 2005 New York NOL deduction on its 2006 franchise tax returndid not effect its tax liability for that year, insofar as its 2007 franchise tax liability was measuredbased upon its ENI, by carrying over the entirety of its 2005 New York NOL deduction,petitioner significantly reduced its franchise tax liability in 2007.

Footnote 6:Rather, by operation of Tax Lawformer § 1455, banking corporations were required to compute their franchise taxdue for a given year applying all four available alternative tax bases and, thereafter, payaccording to whichever alternative tax base resulted in the imposition of the highest tax.

Footnote 7:Notably, in Matter ofBrooke-Bond, the applicable NOL deduction reduced the petitioner's ENI for the given yearto zero. As such, the petitioner's franchise tax liability for that year was, as here, necessarilycalculated utilizing an alternative tax base.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.