Matter of Ayoub v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State ofN.Y.
2015 NY Slip Op 05240 [129 AD3d 1354]
June 18, 2015
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 5, 2015


[*1]
 In the Matter of David Ayoub et al., Petitioners, v TaxAppeals Tribunal of The State of New York et al.,Respondents.

Centolella Lynn D'Elia & Temes, LLC, Syracuse (Timothy M. Lynn ofcounsel), for petitioners.

Eric T. Schneiderman, Attorney General, Albany (Robert M. Goldfarb of counsel),for Commissioner of Taxation and Finance, respondent.

Peters, P.J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuantto Tax Law § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax AppealsTribunal which sustained notices of deficiency of personal income tax imposed underTax Law article 22.

This proceeding concerns petitioners' entitlement to Qualified Empire ZoneEnterprise (hereinafter QEZE) tax reduction credits and refundable Empire Zone(hereinafter EZ) wage credits flowing from their membership interests in an accountingpractice operating under the name Bowers & Company, CPAs, PLLC (hereinafterMGD/Bowers) for the 2006, 2007 and 2008 tax years. The Tax Law provides for taxreduction credits against personal income tax for a member of a partnership that iscertified as a QEZE (see Tax Law §§ 16 [a]; 606 [cc]). AQEZE is defined as "[a] business enterprise" that is certified under General MunicipalLaw article 18-B and meets the employment test (Tax Law § 14 [a]). Forpurposes of the QEZE tax reduction credit, the date that the business enterprise is firstcertified is significant. As to a business enterprise first certified between August 1, 2002and March 31, 2005 with a base period of zero taxable years, the employment test is metonly if the enterprise qualifies as a "new business" (Tax Law § 14 [b] [1];[j] [2]). In contrast, a business enterprise first certified prior to August 1, 2002 need notqualify as a new business to [*2]meet the employmenttest (see Tax Law § 14 [b] [1]).[FN1]

MGD/Bowers was originally formed as a single-member New York limited liabilitycompany as part of a plan to combine the operations of two Syracuse-based accountingfirms—Dermody, Burke & Brown, Certified Public Accountants, P.C.(hereinafter DBB) and Pasquale & Bowers LLP. The single-member PLLCobtained certification as a QEZE under General Municipal Law article 18-B in July 2002and, thereafter, a certificate of amendment of the articles of organization was filedchanging the name of that entity to Dermody, Burke & Brown, Certified PublicAccountants, PLLC (hereinafter Dermody PLLC). In January 2003, Dermody PLLCbegan operations and 20 members were admitted to the practice, 14 of whom had beenshareholders of DBB and the other six of whom had been partners at Pasquale &Bowers.

In July 2004, the members of Dermody PLLC entered into a separation agreementwherein the practice separated in a similar proportion to how it had been formed.Pursuant to that agreement, the former shareholders of DBB had their membershipinterests in Dermody PLLC redeemed and formed a new entity, leaving only the formerpartners of Pasquale & Bowers as members. The separation agreement furtherprovided that the redemptions of the membership interests were, for tax purposes,intended to be treated as an assets-over form division of a partnership whereby one of theresulting partnerships is a continuation of the former partnership. Accordingly,notwithstanding its retention of the corporate form, the post-separation DermodyPLLC—as the resulting partnership whose members had less than a 50% interestin the capital and profits of the prior partnership—became a new partnership forfederal tax purposes (see Internal Revenue Code [26 USC] § 708[b] [2] [B]; 26 CFR 1.708-1 [d] [1]). A certificate of amendment to the entity's articles oforganization was again filed changing its name to MGD/Bowers. MGD/Bowers appliedfor and was granted certification as a QEZE in August 2004.

Following an audit of petitioners' personal income tax returns for the 2006, 2007 and2008 tax years, the Division of Taxation and Finance determined that petitioners werenot entitled to the claimed QEZE tax reduction credits and refundable EZ wage taxcredits and issued notices of deficiency assessing additional personal income tax due,plus interest. After a hearing, an Administrative Law Judge sustained the notices ofdeficiency with certain modifications not relevant here, concluding that MGD/Bowerswas a business enterprise first certified as a QEZE in August 2004, not July 2002, anddid not qualify as a new business pursuant to Tax Law § 14 (j). Thatdetermination was affirmed by respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal, and this CPLR article78 proceeding ensued.

The parties' primary disagreement here centers on whether the term businessenterprise under Tax Law § 14 (a) refers to the taxable entity or the legalentity. The Tax Law does not define business enterprise, and this Court will "defer to thegovernmental agency charged with the responsibility for administration of [a] statute inthose cases where interpretation or application involves knowledge and understanding ofunderlying operational practices" (Matter of New York State Superfund Coalition, Inc. v New YorkState Dept. of Envtl. Conservation, 18 NY3d 289, 296 [2011] [internalquotation marks and citation omitted]; accord Matter of County [*3]ofAlbany v Hudson Riv.-Black Riv. Regulating Dist., 97 AD3d 61, 66-67 [2012],lv denied 19 NY3d 816 [2012]; see Matter of Kent v Cuomo, 124 AD3d 1185, 1186[2015]). While, as a general rule, courts will not defer to administrative agencies inmatters of pure statutory interpretation, where, as here, the question is " 'one ofspecific application of a broad statutory term in a proceeding in which the agencyadministering the statute must determine it initially,' " deference is appropriate(Matter of Easylink Servs. Intl.,Inc. v New York State Tax Appeals Trib., 101 AD3d 1180, 1182 [2012], lvdenied 21 NY3d 858 [2013], quoting Matter of American Tel. & Tel. Co. vState Tax Commn., 61 NY2d 393, 400 [1984]; see Matter of Lyell Mt. Read Bus.Ctr. LLC v Empire Zone Designation Bd., 129 AD3d 137, 148 [2015]; Matter of Stevenson v New York State Tax Appeals Trib., 106AD3d 1146, 1147 [2013]). To prevail over the Tribunal's construction of the statute,petitioners must establish that their "interpretation of the statute is not only plausible, butalso that it is the only reasonable construction" (Matter of Stevenson v New YorkState Tax Appeals Trib., 106 AD3d at 1147 [internal quotation marks and citationsomitted]; see Matter of CharterDev. Co., L.L.C. v City of Buffalo, 6 NY3d 578, 582 [2006]; Matter of 677 New Loudon Corp. vState of N.Y. Tax Appeals Trib., 85 AD3d 1341, 1342 [2011], affd 19NY3d 1058 [2012], cert denied 571 US &mdash, 134 S Ct 422 [2013]).

In our view, it cannot be said that the Tribunal acted irrationally in construing theterm business enterprise in accordance with an entity's classification for state and federalincome tax purposes. As the Tribunal noted, the Tax Law does not allow for QEZE taxreduction credits based upon membership in a limited liability company (hereinafterLLC), such as MGD/Bowers, because such an entity is not recognized for income taxreporting (see Tax Law §§ 16 [a]; 606 [cc]; 26 CFR301.7701-3 [a]). Rather, an LLC is only recognized in accordance with how its memberselect to be treated for state and federal tax purposes, i.e., either as a corporation or apartnership (see Tax Law § 601 [f]). The Tribunal thus logicallyconcluded that Empire Zone attributes—such as a QEZE certification—donot follow the LLC entity, but rather are obtainable only through the reportingclassification chosen by the LLC, and that the question of whether MGD/Bowers shouldbe considered the same business enterprise as that which existed prior to the separationof Dermody PLLC is therefore dependent upon whether it is considered the samepartnership for income tax purposes. As noted, when Dermody PLLC separated into twoseparate partnerships in July 2004, MGD/Bowers became a new partnership for taxpurposes and, accordingly, was considered a separate and distinct business enterprisefrom that certified as a QEZE in July 2002. As the Tribunal rationally determined thatMGD/Bowers, as it existed during the tax years at issue, was first certified as a QEZEbetween August 1, 2002 and March 31, 2005, petitioners' entitlement to the claimedcredits hinged on whether MGD/Bowers qualified as a new business under Tax Law§ 14.[FN2]

A new business is one that is not "substantially similar in operation and inownership" to [*4]a taxable or previously taxablebusiness entity (Tax Law § 14 [j] [2]). There can be no dispute that, duringthe 2006, 2007 and 2008 tax years at issue, the post-separation MGD/Bowers wassubstantially similar in ownership to Pasquale & Bowers, as both entities consistedof the very same members. With regard to its operations, while testimony was presentedregarding several changes that were undertaken following the merger of Pasquale &Bowers and DBB, the Administrative Law Judge took particular note of the fact thatMGD/Bowers' client base following the breakup of Dermody PLLC was the same as thatof Pasquale & Bowers. Moreover, petitioners failed to demonstrate that any suchchanges in operation were made before or during the tax years at issue, as opposed tosome later point in time. Mindful that statutes providing for tax credits are construednarrowly and that the burden of proving entitlement to such credits rests with thetaxpayer (see Matter of Piccolov New York State Tax Appeals Trib., 108 AD3d 107, 111-112 [2013]), weconclude that the Tribunal's finding that MGD/Bowers was substantially similar toPasquale & Bowers is "rationally based upon and supported by substantialevidence" (Matter of Ingle vTax Appeals Trib. of the Dept. of Taxation & Fin. of the State of N.Y., 110AD3d 1392, 1393 [2013] [internal quotation marks and citations omitted]; accord Matter of Luongo v TaxAppeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 117 AD3d 1286, 1289 [2014]; see Matter of Hwang v TaxAppeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 105 AD3d 1151, 1152 [2013]; Matter of Salh v Tax Appeals Trib.of the State of N.Y., 99 AD3d 1124, 1125 [2012], lv denied 20 NY3d863 [2013]). Accordingly, its determination that petitioners were not entitled to theclaimed QEZE tax reduction credits and refundable EZ wage credits must beconfirmed.

Petitioners' remaining contentions, to the extent not specifically addressed herein,have been reviewed and found to be lacking in merit.

Lahtinen, McCarthy and Rose, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:The question regardingthe applicable date of certification is relevant only with regard to petitioners' claims forQEZE tax reduction credits, as claims for refunds of EZ wage credits are subject to thenew business requirement regardless of the date of certification (see Tax Law§ 606 [a] [10] [A]; [k] [5]).

Footnote 2:Petitioners also assertthat, even if the August 2004 certification controls their claims for QEZE tax reductioncredits, MGD/Bowers is still not required to qualify as a new business in order to meetthe employment test because it has a base period of more than zero years (see TaxLaw § 14 [c]). As the Tribunal properly concluded, however, inasmuch asMGD/Bowers was deemed a newly formed partnership upon the separation of DermodyPLLC in 2004, it could not rely upon the tax attributes of the prior, distinct partnership towhich its members no longer belonged.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.