Smyth v McDonald
2012 NY Slip Op 09266 [101 AD3d 1789]
December 28, 2012
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, February 6, 2013


Theresa A. Smyth et al., Respondents,
v
Benjamin J. McDonaldet al., Appellants.

—[*1]Adams, Hanson, Rego, Carlin, Hughes, Kaplan & Fishbein, Williamsville (Bethany A. Rubinof counsel), for defendants-appellants.

The Carey Firm, LLC, Grand Island (Shawn W. Carey of counsel), forplaintiffs-respondents.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Erie County (Frederick J. Marshall, J.), enteredOctober 19, 2011 in a personal injury action. The order denied defendants' motion for summaryjudgment.

It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously reversed on the law withoutcosts, the motion is granted and the complaint is dismissed.

Memorandum: Plaintiffs commenced this action seeking damages for injuries Theresa A. Smyth(plaintiff) allegedly sustained when a vehicle owned by defendants Barbara F. McDonald and Earl L.McDonald and operated by defendant Benjamin J. McDonald rear-ended her vehicle in October 2006.Supreme Court erred in denying defendants' motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint onthe ground that plaintiff did not sustain a serious injury within the meaning of Insurance Law §5102 (d). With respect to the permanent consequential limitation of use and significant limitation of usecategories of serious injury allegedly sustained by plaintiff, defendants met their initial burden on themotion by submitting, inter alia, the records concerning medical treatment received by plaintiffimmediately following the accident, which establish that plaintiff did not sustain a traumatic injury andthat there was an unexplained gap in treatment after plaintiff's last physical therapy visit in January 2007.Plaintiff next sought treatment with her primary care physician in August 2009 and thereafter resumedphysical therapy. Defendants contend that the 31-month gap in plaintiff's treatment is fatal to her claimthat she sustained a serious injury within the meaning of those two categories of serious injury. Weagree. We conclude that plaintiffs failed to raise a triable issue of fact to defeat the motion with respectto those two categories. Plaintiffs submitted, inter alia, the affidavit of a physician who treated plaintifffor her back condition for the first time in October 2009, but they failed to provide a reasonableexplanation for the lengthy gap in treatment (see Pommells v Perez, 4 NY3d 566, 574 [2005]). Thus, although thetreating physician provided objective medical evidence that plaintiff was injured, the 31-month gap intreatment renders his opinion as to causation purely speculative (see Smith v Reeves, 96 AD3d 1550, 1551 [2012]). Plaintiff stoppedattending physical therapy in early 2007 because her primary care physician would not provide a newprescription for physical [*2]therapy and instead recommended thatplaintiff engage in a pain management program. Plaintiff asserted that she chose not to engage in thepain management program because she thought that she would have to take narcotic medication, whichshe was not willing to do, and she hoped that her injury would heal on its own over time. That,however, is not a reasonable explanation for the 31-month gap in treatment, which fatally underminesplaintiffs' claim of serious injury with respect to the permanent consequential limitation of use andsignificant limitation of use categories of serious injury (see Semonian v Seidenberg, 71 AD3d 1562, 1563 [2010]; Wei-San Hsu v Briscoe Protective Sys.,Inc., 43 AD3d 916, 917 [2007]; Colon v Kempner, 20 AD3d 372, 374 [2005]; see generallyPommells, 4 NY3d at 574). Although plaintiffs assert with respect to the gap in treatment thatfurther physical therapy would have been palliative and that plaintiff's request for no-fault benefits wasdenied, those assertions are not supported by the record (cf. Brown v Dunlap, 4 NY3d 566,577 [2005]; Peluso v Janice Taxi Co.,Inc., 77 AD3d 491, 492 [2010]).

With respect to the significant disfigurement category of serious injury alleged by plaintiffs, wefurther conclude that defendants met their initial burden on the motion (see generally Zuckerman vCity of New York, 49 NY2d 557, 562 [1980]). In addition, plaintiffs failed to raise an issue of factwhether plaintiff sustained such an injury because the alleged disfigurement of plaintiff's scapula, ofwhich in any event there is no photograph in the record, is not readily observable to others (see Mahar v Bartnick, 91 AD3d 1163,1166 [2012]; see also Wiegand v Schunck, 294 AD2d 839, 839 [2002]), and plaintiffs didnot present evidence that "a reasonable person viewing the plaintiff's [scapula] in its altered state wouldregard the condition as unattractive, objectionable or as the subject of pity or scorn" (O'Brien v Bainbridge, 89 AD3d 1511,1513 [2011] [internal quotation marks omitted]).

Finally, with respect to the 90/180-day category of serious injury alleged by plaintiffs, we concludethat defendants met their initial burden by submitting plaintiff's "medical records establishing that thereare no 'objective medical findings of a medically determined injury or impairment of a nonpermanentnature which caused the alleged limitations on [her] daily activities' within 90 of the 180 daysimmediately following the occurrence of the injury or impairment" (Harrity v Leone, 93 AD3d 1204, 1205 [2012]). Plaintiffs failed to raisean issue of fact with respect to that category. The affidavit of plaintiff's treating physician, based uponhis treatment of plaintiff beginning three years after the accident, is "too remote to be probative ofplaintiff's accident-related claim" and is therefore insufficient to raise an issue of fact as to the causal linkbetween plaintiff's alleged injuries and her limitations within the 180 days following the accident (Whisenant v Farazi, 67 AD3d 535,536 [2009]; see Smith, 96 AD3d at 1552). Present—Scudder, P.J., Smith, Fahey,Carni and Martoche, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.