Reeves v Giannotta
2015 NY Slip Op 05796 [130 AD3d 1444]
July 2, 2015
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 2, 2015


[*1]
 Paula Ann Reeves, Respondent,
v
Gary J.Giannotta, as Chief of Auburn Police Department, et al., Appellants, et al.,Defendants.

Lemire, Johnson & Higgins, LLC, Malta (Bradley J. Stevens of counsel), fordefendants-appellants.

Stewart L. Weisman, Manlius, for plaintiff-respondent.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Cayuga County (Mark H. Fandrich,A.J.), entered February 19, 2014. The order, inter alia, denied the motion ofdefendants-appellants for summary judgment dismissing the complaint against them.

It is hereby ordered that the order so appealed from is unanimously reversed on thelaw without costs, the motion of defendants-appellants is granted, and the complaint isdismissed against them.

Memorandum: Plaintiff commenced this action alleging that "[d]efendantsintentionally interfered with [her] right of possession of . . . [f]irearms" thatthe police removed from her parents' home while executing a warrant for their arrest forselling drugs. According to plaintiff, "a couple of months" after her parents werearrested, she and her mother agreed that plaintiff would receive the firearms in exchangefor the money that plaintiff gave to her parents for legal fees. When plaintiff contactedthe Auburn Police Department, personally and through her attorney, trying to retrieve thefirearms, she and her attorney were told that plaintiff had to obtain a court order toretrieve the firearms. County Court issued an order on December 10, 2010, awardingplaintiff ownership and possession of the firearms (Dec. 2010 order), but the police hadalready destroyed the firearms. We conclude that Supreme Court erred in denying themotion of defendants-appellants (defendants) for summary judgment dismissing thecomplaint against them.

"An actionable 'conversion takes place when someone, intentionally and withoutauthority, assumes or exercises control over personal property belonging to someoneelse, interfering with that person's right of possession' " (LM Bus. Assoc., Inc. v State ofNew York, 124 AD3d 1215, 1216-1217 [2015], lv denied 25 NY3d 905[2015], quoting Colavito v NewYork Organ Donor Network, Inc., 8 NY3d 43, 49-50 [2006]). "Two keyelements of conversion are (1) plaintiff's possessory right or interest in the property. . . and (2) defendant's dominion over the property or interference with it, inderogation of plaintiff's rights" (Colavito, 8 NY3d at 50).

Defendants met their initial burden with respect to both elements, and plaintiff failedto raise a triable issue of fact (see generally Zuckerman v City of New York, 49NY2d 557, 562 [1980]). With respect to the first element, defendants established thatplaintiff did not have a possessory right or interest in the firearms, and plaintiff failed toraise an issue of fact in that regard. We reject plaintiff's contention that she hadpossessory rights to the firearms based on the December 2010 order. The cause of actionfor conversion accrued when the firearms were destroyed or, as plaintiff alternativelyalleges, misappropriated by members of the police department after plaintiff made ademand for them, over a month before plaintiff obtained the court order (see Pecoraro v M&T BankCorp., 11 AD3d 950, 951 [2004]; Johnson v Gumer, 94 AD2d 955, 955[1983]). Thus, we conclude that defendants established that "plaintiff did not own, orhave possessory rights to, the property when any such cause[ ] of action accrued" (Wild v Hayes, 68 AD3d1412, 1414 [2009]).

Likewise, we reject plaintiff's contention that she had possessory rights to thefirearms based on an agreement with her mother. Plaintiff failed to raise an issue of factwith her self-serving deposition testimony that her mother agreed to give her the firearmsin exchange for assistance with legal fees, and she otherwise failed to submit anyevidence to raise an issue of fact whether she had a right of possession superior to that ofthe police who previously seized the firearms (see Williams v Pinks, Feldman &Brooks, 141 AD2d 723, 724 [1988], lv denied 73 NY2d 701 [1988]; seealso LM Bus. Assoc., Inc., 124 AD3d at 1217-1218). In addition, plaintiff'sallegation that the firearms were misappropriated rather than destroyed "is toospeculative to survive defendants' motion for summary judgment" (Lincoln Trust v Spaziano, 118AD3d 1399, 1401 [2014];see Stewart v Kier, 100 AD3d 1389, 1390 [2012]).

With respect to the second element, defendants established that their exercise ofcontrol over the firearms was authorized, and plaintiff failed to raise an issue of fact.Defendants were authorized to seize the firearms from plaintiff's parents pursuant toPenal Law § 400.05, and the same statute directed that those firearms bedestroyed absent, inter alia, a "certificate" from a court or a district attorney directing thatthey be preserved (see § 400.05 [2], [3]). It is undisputed thatplaintiff did not attempt to have the firearms returned to her until the spring of 2010,approximately a year and a half after the firearms were seized, and Penal Law§ 400.05 (2) provides for automatic destruction of seized firearms "at leastonce each year." Inasmuch as plaintiff did not formally challenge the validity of theseizure prior to the firearms' destruction and she conceded at her deposition that she wasnot the lawful owner of the firearms until she received the December 2010 order,defendants' seizure and destruction of the firearms was authorized by statute and does notconstitute conversion (see LM Bus. Assoc., Inc., 124 AD3d at 1217).

In light of our determination, we do not address defendants' remaining contentions.Present—Scudder, P.J., Centra, Peradotto, Sconiers and Valentino, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.