| Matter of Mattice v Hammond |
| 2015 NY Slip Op 06637 [131 AD3d 790] |
| August 20, 2015 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Thomas Mattice,Appellant, v Michael S. Hammond et al., Respondents, et al., Respondents. (AndAnother Related Proceeding.) |
James E. Long, Albany, for appellant.
Law Offices of James E. Walsh, Ballston Spa (James E. Walsh of counsel), forMichael S. Hammond and another, respondents.
Per Curiam. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (McGill, J.), entered August6, 2015 in St. Lawrence County, which, among other things, dismissed petitioner'sapplication, in a proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, to declareinvalid the designating petition naming respondents Michael S. Hammond and MeganMartin as candidates for the party positions of delegate and alternate delegate,respectively, to the Conservative Party Judicial Nominating Convention, Fourth JudicialDistrict, from the 117th Assembly District in the September 10, 2015 primaryelection.
Respondents Michael S. Hammond and Megan Martin (hereinafter collectivelyreferred to as respondents) filed a designating petition with the St. Lawrence CountyBoard of Elections seeking to be nominated as candidates for the positions of delegateand alternate delegate, respectively, to the Conservative Party Judicial NominatingConvention, Fourth Judicial District, from the 117th Assembly District. Petitioner filedwritten objections with the Board challenging the designating petition (seeElection Law § 6-154) and, shortly thereafter, commenced the instantproceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102 seeking to invalidate thedesignating petition on the basis of fraud. Following a hearing, Supreme Court foundthat the designating petition was not permeated by fraud and, accordingly, dismissedpetitioner's application. Petitioner now appeals.
[*2] A court will invalidate a designating petition where thechallenger establishes, by clear and convincing evidence, "that the entire petition ispermeated with fraud or that the candidate participated in, or can be charged withknowledge of, fraudulent activity" (Matter of VanSavage v Jones, 120 AD3d 887, 888 [2014][internal quotation marks and citations omitted], lv dismissed 23 NY3d 1045[2014], lv denied 24 NY3d 901 [2014]; see Matter of Haygood v Hardwick, 110 AD3d 931, 932[2013]). Where a candidate is involved in the fraud, the challenger need not show thatthe fraud permeated the entire petition (see Matter of Haygood v Hardwick, 110AD3d at 932; Matter of Valentiv Bugbee, 88 AD3d 1056, 1057 [2011]), and "the petition may be invalidatedeven if it contains a sufficient number of valid signatures independent of thosefraudulently procured" (Matter of Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d at 1057 [internalquotation marks and citation omitted]; see Matter of Cirillo v Gardiner, 65 AD3d 638, 639[2009]).
Here, the evidence adduced at the hearing established that the designating petitionconsisted of four sheets and a total of 38 signatures, 30 more than the eight required toreceive the party designation. On each sheet, Hammond signed the subscribing witnessstatement attesting that each individual who signed his or her name did so in Hammond'spresence and identified himself or herself as the individual who signed. It is undisputed,however, that three of the signatures on sheet two were signed, in Hammond's presence,by the spouse of the individual whose signature it was attributed to. Hammond testifiedthat he was unaware at the time that he obtained the signatures that spouses could notsign for each other. Notwithstanding this mistaken belief, Hammond admitted that hefalsely attested in the witness statement that each individual signed his or her name in hispresence and that he also filed his designating petition knowing that three of thesignatures were not signed by the individuals to whom they were attributed.
Based upon the foregoing, we find that petitioner established by clear and convincingevidence that Hammond signed the witness statement on sheet two despite knowing thatsuch statement was false (see Matter of Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d at 1058;Matter of Cirillo v Gardiner, 65 AD3d at 639). In reaching the conclusion that thedesignating petition was not permeated by fraud, Supreme Court found that, althoughHammond's signature on the witness statement on sheet two was false, Hammond lackedan intent to deceive. Fraud, however, does not require proof of a "nefarious motive"(Matter of Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d at 1058). Inasmuch as Hammondparticipated in the fraud, and regardless of the fact that the designating petition containeda sufficient number of signatures independent of the three signatures that werefraudulently obtained, we invalidate respondents' designating petition and strike theirnames from the ballot (see Matter of Haygood v Hardwick, 110 AD3d at 933;Matter of Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d at 1058; Matter of Leonard vPradhan, 286 AD2d 459, 459 [2001], lv denied 96 NY2d 718 [2001]).
Lahtinen, J.P., McCarthy, Garry and Lynch, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order ismodified, on the law, without costs, by reversing so much thereof as dismissed theapplication seeking to declare invalid the designating petition naming respondentsMichael S. Hammond and Megan Martin as candidates for the party positions of delegateand alternate delegate, respectively, to the Conservative Party Judicial NominatingConvention, Fourth Judicial District, from the 117th Assembly District in the September10, 2015 primary election; said application granted and said designating petition declaredinvalid; and, as so modified, affirmed.