Matter of Harvey v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of the City ofKingston
2018 NY Slip Op 07395 [166 AD3d 1149]
November 1, 2018
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, January 2, 2018


[*1]
 In the Matter of Hillary Harvey et al.,Appellants,
v
Zoning Board of Appeals of the City of Kingston et al.,Respondents.

Warren S. Replansky, PC, Rhinebeck (Warren S. Replansky of counsel), forappellants.

Kevin R. Bryant, Corporation Counsel, Kingston (Daniel Gartenstein of counsel), forZoning Board of Appeals of the City of Kingston and another, respondents.

Ronald S. Pordy, Kingston, for Irish Cultural Center Hudson Valley, Inc.,respondent.

Devine, J. Appeal from a judgment of the Supreme Court (Mott, J.), entered May 23,2017, in Ulster County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in a combinedproceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 and action for declaratory judgment, to review adetermination of respondent Zoning Board of Appeals of the City of Kingston findingthat the use of a premises belonging to respondent Irish Cultural Center Hudson Valley,Inc. was permitted under the Code of the City of Kingston.

Respondent Irish Cultural Center Hudson Valley, Inc. (hereinafter ICC) owns realproperty in the City of Kingston, Ulster County that borders Abeel Street as well as amunicipal walkway running downhill to a street known as the West Strand. ICC aims tobuild a three-story cultural center on the property that will have its primary entrance onthe walkway and include a theater, exhibition and gallery space, classrooms, a library anda restaurant. Pursuant to the City's zoning ordinance, the cultural center must have "directfrontage . . . on the West Strand" for the bulk of those uses to be permissible(Code of City of Kingston § 405-19 [B] [1]).

Petitioners are residential landowners on Abeel Street and asked respondent JosephSafford, the Zoning Enforcement Officer for the City of Kingston (hereinafter ZEO), todetermine whether the ICC property had the requisite direct frontage on the West Strand(see Code of City of Kingston § 405-19 [B] [1]). The ZEO foundthat it did and, upon review, respondent Zoning Board of Appeals of the City ofKingston (hereinafter ZBA) agreed. Petitioners commenced this combined CPLR article78 proceeding and declaratory judgment [*2]action to,among other things, annul the ZBA's determination. Supreme Court dismissed thepetition/complaint following joinder of issue, and petitioners now appeal.

We affirm. Petitioners initially argue that the ZBA failed to give them the requisiteopportunity to respond to a letter, submitted after the public hearing on petitioners'administrative appeal and cited in the ensuing determination, from a land surveyorretained by the ZBA to review the relevant public records and describe the relation of theICC property to the municipal walkway and the West Strand. The ZBA disclosed that itwas waiting for requested information before rendering its determination, however, andthat pronouncement drew no objection from petitioners. The letter itself containsinformation that closely tracks the findings of the ZEO, and petitioners further fail to setforth what, if anything, is inaccurate in it. Accordingly, while it may have been "unwise"for the ZBA to consider the letter without affording petitioners an opportunity torespond, that misstep "should [not] serve as a basis for annulling the determination"under the facts presented (Matter of De Blois v Wallace, 88 AD2d 1073, 1074[1982]; see Matter ofApplebaum v Village of Great Neck Bd. of Appeals, 138 AD3d 830, 831[2016]; Matter of W.W.W. Assoc. v Rettaliata, 175 AD2d 133, 134 [1991]).

Petitioners next complain that the ZBA privately met with its counsel following thepublic hearing to grapple with the legal issues involved, retain the aforementionedsurveyor and direct counsel to draft the detailed written determination that it publiclyadopted. Assuming without deciding that this conduct violated the Open Meetings Law(see Public Officers Law art 7), it rendered the ZBA's determination" 'not void but, rather, voidable' upon good cause shown" (Matter of Oakwood Prop. Mgt.,LLC v Town of Brunswick, 103 AD3d 1067, 1070 [2013], lv denied 21NY3d 853 [2013], quoting Matter of Ireland v Town of Queensbury Zoning Bd. ofAppeals, 169 AD2d 73, 76 [1991], lv dismissed 79 NY2d 822 [1991]).Petitioners have not articulated how these encounters—which appear to be aneffort by the ZBA to properly respond to information that had been fully aired anddiscussed in public—"were part of an effort to thwart public scrutiny of [theZBA's] process in deliberate violation of the Open Meetings Law" (Matter of Haverstraw OwnersProfessionals & Entrepreneurs ["H.O.P.E.''] v Town of Ramapo Zoning Bd. ofAppeals, 151 AD3d 724, 725 [2017]). It follows that petitioners have "failed intheir burden of demonstrating good cause warranting the exercise of our discretionarypower to nullify the" determination (Matter of MCI Telecom. Corp. v Public Serv.Commn. of State of N.Y., 231 AD2d 284, 291 [1997]; see Matter of Catskill HeritageAlliance, Inc. v Crossroads Ventures, LLC, 161 AD3d 1413, 1417 [2018]).

Turning to the merits of the determination, inasmuch as the ZBA confronted factualissues that went beyond a "pure legal interpretation," its interpretation of the "localzoning ordinance is afforded deference and will only be disturbed if irrational orunreasonable" (Matter ofLavender v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of the Town of Bolton, 141 AD3d 970, 972[2016], appeal dismissed 28 NY3d 1051 [2016], lv denied 29 NY3d 907[2017]; see Matter ofBlanchfield v Town of Hoosick, 149 AD3d 1380, 1382 [2017]). The permitteduses for the ICC property are dictated by whether it has "direct frontage . . .on the West Strand" (Code of the City of Kingston § 405-19 [B] [1]), withfrontage defined as "[t]he linear distance of a lot along the street line" (Code of the Cityof Kingston § 405-3). As the ZBA recognized, "direct frontage" on a streetdoes not imply that the property boundary must be flush with the pavement. A sidewalkis "part of the street or highway" (Pardi v Barone, 257 AD2d 42, 44 [1999];see Vehicle and Traffic Law § 144), and sidewalks are defined inthe Code of the City of Kingston as "[t]he distance from the property line of any premisesto the curbline" (Code of the City of Kingston § 355-17; see alsoCastiglione v Village of Ellenville, 291 AD2d 769, 770 [2002], lv denied 98NY2d 604 [2002]). The record reflects that the municipal walkway bordering the ICCproperty merges with the West Strand, and both the ZEO and the surveyor retained bythe ZBA stated that this merger between the walkway and the street occurred along theICC's property boundary. The ZBA accordingly determined that the ICC property haddirect frontage along the West Strand and that, as a result, the property could be used forthe purposes enumerated in Code of the City of Kingston § 405-19 (B) (1).Notwithstanding the alternative interpretations proffered by petitioners, which find littlesupport in the language of the zoning ordinance itself, the ZBA's determination wasreasonable.

[*3] Petitioners only asked foran interpretation as to whether the ICC property had "direct frontage" on the West Strandat the administrative level and, as such, cannot argue that the ZBA erred in notaddressing whether a pub and restaurant proposed for the cultural center was a permitteduse under Code of the City of Kingston § 405-19 (B) (1) (see Matter of Kearney v Village ofCold Spring Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 83 AD3d 711, 713 [2011]). To the extentthat petitioners seek a declaratory judgment on whether that use was permitted, they havefailed to exhaust their administrative remedies (see Matter of One Niagara LLC v City of Niagara Falls, 78AD3d 1554, 1555-1556 [2010]). Their remaining contentions have been examinedand lack merit.

McCarthy, J.P., Aarons, Rumsey and Pritzker, JJ., concur. Ordered that the judgmentis affirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.