| People v Ajunwa |
| 2022 NY Slip Op 50977(U) [76 Misc 3d 1217(A)] |
| Decided on October 7, 2022 |
| Criminal Court Of The City Of New York, Bronx County |
| Licitra, J. |
| This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports. |
Decided on October 7, 2022
The People of theState of New York against Ajunwa, Defendant. |
Docket No. CR-013585-21BX
For the People: Darcel Clark, District Attorney of Bronx County (by ADA MeredithHoltzman)
For Ms. Ajunwa: The Legal Aid Society (by Ilana Kornfeld)
Wanda L. Licitra, J.
The People move for leave to reargue the court's July 7, 2022, decision granting the defense'sC.P.L. § 30.30 motion to dismiss. (People v. Ajunwa, 75 Misc 3d 1220[A] [Crim. Ct., Bronx County2022]). In that decision, the court found that the People failed to establish that they dischargedtheir discovery duties before certifying compliance with those duties. (Id.). Uponconsideration of the People's motion for leave to reargue, as well as the defense's response, thePeople's request for leave to reargue is denied.
The Criminal Procedure Law generally does notprovide for leave to reargue,[FN1]but the Civil Practice Law and Rules does. (See C.P.L.R. § 2221). As a result,criminal courts often apply the rules of C.P.L.R. § 2221 to motions for leave to reargue.(E.g., People v. Benitez, 75Misc 3d 1204[A], at *2 [Dist. Ct., Suffolk County 2022]; People v. Roberts, 76 Misc 3d 448,452 [Crim. Ct., NY County 2022]; People v. Manzueta, 62 Misc 3d 187, 189 [Crim. Ct., QueensCounty 2018]; People v. Wilson, 50Misc 3d 1224[A], at *1-*3 [Crim. Ct., Bronx County 2016]; People v. Merly, 51 Misc 3d 858,859-60 [Sup. Ct., Bronx County 2016]; People v. Williams, 48 Misc 3d 1217[A] [Crim. Ct., Bronx County2015]; People v. Garraway, 47 Misc3d 1227[A], at *1-*3 [Crim. Ct., Bronx County 2015]; People v. Ramrup, 47 Misc 3d 1223[A], at *1-*3 [Sup. Ct., BronxCounty 2015]; but see People v. DeFreitas, 48 Misc 3d 569 [Crim. Ct., NY County2015]).
A motion for "reargument" must be "based upon matters of fact or law allegedly overlookedor misapprehended by the court in determining the prior motion, but shall not include any mattersof fact not offered on the prior motion." (C.P.L.R. § 2221[d][2]). A motion to [*2]reargue is not "'designed to afford the unsuccessful party successiveopportunities to reargue issues previously decided . . . or to present arguments different fromthose originally asserted.'" (Setters v. AI Properties and Developments (USA) Corp., 139AD3d 492, 492 [1st Dep't 2016] [quoting William P. Pahl Equip. Corp. v. Kassis, 182AD2d 22, 27 [1st Dep't 1992]]). Here, the court finds no reason to grant leave to reargue.
First, the People fail to identify any matters of law that the court misapprehended. Instead,they only restate their incorrect legal arguments from their prior briefing. Specifically, they arguethat the adverse-consequence clause applies to trial-readiness determinations. (Pr. Mot. at 12-13).This court has rejected that argument on multiple occasions. (E.g., People v.Alvia, 172 N.Y.S.3d 892, 895-96 [Crim. Ct., Bronx County 2022]; People v. Carrillo, 75 Misc 3d1227[A], at *3 [Crim. Ct., Bronx County 2022]; People v. Vargas, 171 N.Y.S.3d877, 880-81 [Crim. Ct., Bronx County 2022]). Other courts have also rejected the argument.(E.g., People v. Darren, 75Misc 3d 1208[A], at *6 [Crim. Ct., NY County 2022]; People v. Martinez, 75 Misc 3d 1212[A], at *6 [Crim. Ct., NYCounty 2022]; People v. Formicola,74 Misc 3d 559, 564-65 [Just. Ct., Monroe County 2022]; People v. Aquino, 72 Misc 3d 518,526-27 [Crim. Ct., Kings County 2021]; People v. Quinlan, 71 Misc 3d 266, 272 [Crim. Ct., Bronx County2021]; see also People ex rel. Ferro v.Brann, 197 AD3d 787, 787-88 [2d Dep't 2021] [deciding whether a COC supported astatement of trial readiness without referring to the adverse-consequence clause]). And, earlierthis year, when the Governor sought to amend the adverse-consequence clause to includetrial-readiness determinations, the Legislature rejected it, as well. (See Carrillo, 75 Misc3d 1227[A], at *3; see also Amer. Airlines Inc. v. State Comm. for Human Rights, 29AD2d 178, 181 [1st Dep't 1968] ["In addition, the rejection of the Legislature of the amendments. . . sought by the Commission . . . is significant circumstance against the construction sought by[them]."]). That the People disagree with this court, other courts, and the Legislature is not abasis to grant leave to reargue.
Second, the People fail to identify any matters of fact that the court overlooked. The courtsquarely addressed the alleged ability of the defense to subpoena medical records and FDNYrecords. (See Ajunwa, 75 Misc 3d 1220[A], at *3-*4). Just because the defense canobtain documents by subpoena does not mean that the People are absolved from doinganything regarding those documents. (See id.). To the contrary, the People mustmake a "diligent, good faith effort" to ascertain the existence of discoverable material and causeit to be made available "where it exists but is not within the prosecutor's possession,custody or control." (C.P.L. § 245.20[2] [emphasis added]). If the defense can subpoena adocument, the statute only relieves the People from serving a subpoena to fulfill that"diligent, good faith effort." (See id.). In this case, however, the People did not evencommunicate with the FDNY—or do anything regarding the complainant'smedical records—until months after they filed their certificate of discovery compliance.(Ajunwa, 75 Misc 3d 1220[A], at *3-*4).
The court also squarely addressed the People's original proffered justification for failing todisclose the NYPD animal bite report—that, in their view, it was "duplicative" ofinformation contained in other, different police reports. (See Ajunwa, 75 Misc 3d1220[A], at *4). In fact, the People claimed that "'[t]he only difference with respect to the[disclosed] complaint report and the [undisclosed] animal bite report is the title of thedocument.'" (Id. [quoting Pr. Resp. at 6]). [*3]Uponreviewing that complaint report and the animal bite report, the court found that claim to be"wholly untrue." (Id.). The People gave no other justification for their failure to disclosethe animal bite report in their original opposition or surreply. (Id.). That the People nowclaim, for the first time, that they were "apparently unaware" of the report's "existence" is a newfact in their motion to reargue. (See Pr. Mot. at 13-15). Such new facts are notappropriate here. (See C.P.L.R. § 2221[d][2] [a motion to reargue "shall not includeany matters of fact not offered on the prior motion"]). In any event, this new fact would make nodifference, as it would betray any claim of diligence on the People's certificate of compliance.(See C.P.L. § 245.50[1]). Again, the NYPD animal bite report was referenced in anNYPD Omniform System complaint report, a basic case document of which the People were inpossession. (See Def. Mot. ¶ 17; Pr. Resp. Ex. 4). As Judge Shari Ruth Michelsaptly reasoned in People v. Valentine:
By simply reading her own file, the prosecutor would have realized that there wasindeed an aided report. Instead, it was not until after defense counsel pointed to the specificmemo book entry, that the prosecutor obtained and eventually disclosed the report. If, as here,defense counsel examines the prosecution's discovery materials and points to clear references thatother undisclosed discoverable items exist, the Court cannot find that the prosecutionacted reasonably and diligently.(2019BX030896, at *9 [Crim. Ct., Bronx County June 4, 2021] [Michels, J.]).
Third, nothingin the court's decision relied on facts that were outside of the record. The court's introductoryparagraph—observing a pattern of Bronx prosecutors filing incomplete discovery, late,and then blaming defense counsel—was not a part of the court's legal analysis.Nevertheless, courts are not barred from observing such patterns in their own dockets tocontextualize a decision. (See, e.g., People v. Beshiri, 75 Misc 3d 1206[A], at *1[Crim. Ct., Bronx County 2022] [Zimmerman, J.] [observing that "it is not uncommon in theBronx for lawyers to ignore motion schedules"]; People v. Rodriguez, 76 Misc 3d 494, 499 [Sup. Ct., NY County2022] [Mandelbaum, J.] [observing that the court "has a full inventory" of cases of "dailyinstances of gun violence that garner little attention"]; People v. Isaac, 7 Misc 3d1004[A], at *2 & n.1 [Sup. Ct., Queens County 2005] [Rotker, J.] ["[A] court may also takejudicial notice of the records of another action in the same court."]; see also Francis C.Amendola et al., 57 New York Jurisprudence — Evidence and Witnesses § 40 [2ded. 2022] ["The courts may take judicial notice of actions taken by public officers andgovernmental bodies."]).
One last thing is worth mentioning: the People have moved the court to "issue a newdecision that removes any reference to [the assigned prosecutor] ADA Tracey by name and anysuggestion that the incorrect date [on the People's subpoena] was anything other than a mistake."(Pr. Mot. at 20). The People are referencing a subpoena that ADA Tracey submitted to this court,as an exhibit to his original opposition, that was dated "9/21/2021." (See Ajunwa, 75Misc 3d 1220[A], at *3). In their original papers, the People did not explain why the subpoenabore that date, even after it was pointed out by defense counsel in their reply, and even thoughthe People had the opportunity to do so in their surreply. As a result, the court was left with anexhibit from the People that—with no explanation—was dated before thePeople had filed their certificate of [*4]discovery compliance. Ifthat date were accurate, that evidence would have been material to the court's decision. It wouldhave shown that the People made some timely efforts to ascertain the existence of medicalrecords and make them available. (See C.P.L. § 245.20[2]). Without anyexplanation or acknowledgement from the People as to why the subpoena bore a September date,the court was required to thoroughly reason whether it could "possibly be true." (Ajunwa,75 Misc 3d 1220[A], at *3).
Contrary to the People's characterization, (see Pr. Mot. at 19), the court didnot conclude that ADA Tracey "had acted unethically." (Ajunwa, 75 Misc 3d1220[A], at *3). Instead, the court admonished ADA Tracey "against submitting documents forconsideration that may mislead a tribunal, especially without noting to a court that a material dateis incorrect." (Id.). The court was right to do so. It takes the People's statements, papers,and exhibits seriously, and it expects prosecutors to act with diligence and care. Anadmonishment was appropriate. The court will not "remove[] any reference" to ADA Tracey'sname. (Pr. Mot. at 20). It is elementary that lawyers must file appearances on the record and thatwritten decisions should include the appearances of counsel. In fact, the Law Reporting Bureaurequires it.[FN2]There is no right to prosecute a criminal case anonymously.
The People's motion for leave to reargue is denied.
The foregoing constitutes the order and decision of the court.
Bronx, NYOctober 7, 2022
Wanda L. Licitra, J.C.C.
Footnote 1:There is at least one exception.(See C.P.L. § 470.50 [reargument or reconsideration of an appeal]). There are alsolimited provisions for motions to renew. (See C.P.L. § 710.40[4] [renewal of amotion to suppress before or during trial]; C.P.L. § 730.60[4] [renewal of defense motionsmade while a person is unfit to proceed]).
Footnote 2:See New York State LawReporting Bureau, New York Official Reports, Electronic Format Guides for SubmittingTrial Court Opinions,https://nycourts.gov/reporter/Format.shtml["Please include appearances of counsel with all submissions."].