| People v Martinez |
| 2022 NY Slip Op 50476(U) [75 Misc 3d 1212(A)] |
| Decided on June 8, 2022 |
| Criminal Court Of The City Of New York, New York County |
| Rosenthal, J. |
| This opinion is uncorrected and will not bepublished in the printed Official Reports. |
Decided on June 8, 2022
The People of theState of New York against Ezequiel Martinez, Defendant. |
Docket No. CR-018924-21NY
Defense counsel: Aleksandra Ciric, Legal Aid Society of New York
Forthe People: Alvin Bragg, District Attorney, New York County, by Thomas Kendris
Robert Rosenthal, J.
By motion filed March 1, 2022, defendant moves for an order deeming invalid the People'scertificates of compliance (COC), and dismissing the accusatory instrument pursuant to CriminalProcedure Law § 30.30 (1) (b). The People filed a response on March 17, 2022. Defendantreplied on March 29, 2022. On May 18, 2022, the court, after a review of the motion papers,exhibits, and the court file, on the record in open court, granted defendant's motion to dismiss.This Decision and Order provides the court's reasoning.
Relevant Facts and Procedural History
On August18, 2021, defendant was arraigned on an accusatory instrument charging him with forcibletouching (Penal Law § 130.52 [1]) and forcible touching (Penal Law § 130.52 [2]),class A misdemeanors, and sexual abuse in the third degree (Penal Law § 130.55), a class Bmisdemeanor. Bail was set and the case was adjourned to August 23, 2021, pursuant to CPL170.70, for conversion of the criminal complaint to an information.
On the court date of August 23, 2021, supporting depositions were filed, the complaint wasdeemed an information, and the securing order was modified from bail to supervised release. Thecase was adjourned to October 4, 2021, for trial.
On the court date of October 4, 2021, the People were not ready for trial, and the case wasadjourned to November 9, 2021, for trial.
On October 18, 2021, the People filed and served a purported COC, certificate of readiness(COR), automatic discovery form (ADF), and list of discovery and Rosario materials,including disclosure advisory forms (DAF) for three testifying officers, off-calendar.
On November 8, 2021, the People served a purported supplemental COC, off-calendar.
On the court date of November 9, 2021, the People announced ready for trial. Defendant wasnot ready, and the case was adjourned to December 9, 2021, for trial. On this date, defensecounsel [*2]emailed the People requesting discovery that had notbeen disclosed, including the following items that are relevant to this motion: a property voucher,clarification on which officers would be testifying, underlying disciplinary records for thetestifying officers, a New York City Police Department (NYPD) "scratch 61" complaint reportwork sheet, and NYPD Special Victims Unit (SVU) officers' names and DD5s.
On November 16, 2021, the People filed and served a second purported supplemental COC,a new ADF, and a COR, off-calendar. This purported COC included all documents andinformation requested in defense counsel's aforementioned email, with the exception of NYPDdisciplinary records.
On November 30, 2021, defendant filed and served an omnibus motion, off-calendar. ThePeople filed their response on December 8, 2021.
On the court date of December 9, 2021, the court granted Wade, Mapp, andDunaway hearings, and the case was adjourned to January 26, 2022, for hearings andtrial.
On the court date of January 26, 2022, the People were not ready for hearings and trialbecause the assigned Assistant District Attorney was unavailable and requested an adjournmentto February 1, 2022. The case was adjourned to February 8, 2022, for hearings and trial.
On the court date of February 8, 2022, the People announced ready. At defendant's request, amotion schedule was set. The case was adjourned to April 18, 2022, for decision.
On February 22, 2022, the People filed a third purported supplemental COC, ADF, andCOR, off-calendar.
On March 15, 2022, the People filed a superseding information dated September 4, 2021,which had never been filed or disclosed, off-calendar.
On the court date of April 18, 2022, the case was adjourned to May 18, 2022, fordecision.[FN1]
Discussion
Criminal Procedure Law § 30.30
Defendant isaccused of a misdemeanor offense punishable by a sentence of imprisonment of more than threemonths. Accordingly, the People must be ready for trial within 90 days of the commencement ofthe criminal action, less any excludable time (CPL 30.30 [1] [b] [4]). Computation for speedytrial purposes commences on the day after arraignment (People v Stiles, 70 NY2d 765[1987]). Once a defendant has alleged an unexcused delay greater than the statutory allowance,the burden shifts to the People to demonstrate that specific periods of delay should be excluded(People v Santos, 68 NY2d 859 [1986]; People v Berkowitz, 50 NY2d 333[1980]).
Defendant argues that more than 90 days of includable time have elapsed since thecommencement of the criminal action because the People's purported COCs were invalid, as thePeople failed to disclose items within their possession either at all, or in accordance with CPL245.20 and 30.30 (5) (a). According to defendant, the People declined to disclose underlying[*3]records related to substantiated and unsubstantiatedmisconduct for testifying officers, names and contact information for civilian outcry witnesses,and written statements by the complaining witness to those witnesses. Also according todefendant, the People belatedly disclosed an NYPD property voucher and photographs for aMetrocard seized as evidence, a "scratch 61" worksheet and online booking system arrestworksheet, names and affiliation of SVU personnel, SVU DD5s, a video-taped interrogation,designation of testifying law enforcement witnesses, and a signed criminal court complaint.
The People's refusal to disclose the information and material underlying the misconductallegations requires that defendant's motion be granted. Thus, this decision does not address theother items that, according to defendant, were disclosed belatedly or not at all.
Trial Readiness is Contingent on Compliance with CPL245.20
Pursuant to CPL 245.20 (1), the People must automatically disclose todefendant "all items and information that relate to the subject matter of the case and are in thepossession, custody or control of the prosecution or persons under the prosecution's direction orcontrol." "[A]ll items and information related to the prosecution of a charge in the possession ofany New York state or local police or law enforcement agency shall be deemed to be in thepossession of the prosecution" (CPL 245.20 [2]). CPL 245.20 (2) further directs the People tomake a diligent, good faith effort to ascertain the existence of such information, and when itexists, make it available for discovery, even if the material is not within their possession,custody, or control.
Once the People have satisfied their automatic discovery requirements, they must file andserve a COC pursuant to CPL 245.50. The COC shall identify the items provided and shall statethat, "after exercising due diligence and making reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence ofmaterial and information subject to discovery, the prosecutor has disclosed and made availableall known material and information subject to discovery" (CPL 245.50 [1]). The filing of a COCcannot be deemed complete "until all of the material and information identified in the certificateas subject to discovery . . . was actually produced to the defendant, pursuant to CPL 245.50 (1)and (3)" (People ex rel. Ferro vBrann, 197 AD3d 787, 787 [2d Dept 2021], citing People v Aquino, 72 Misc 3d 518, 523 [Crim Ct, NY County2021]).
Pursuant to CPL 30.30 (5), the People cannot be deemed ready for trial until a proper COC isfiled with the court and served upon the defense. Additionally, pursuant to CPL 245.50 (3), "theprosecution shall not be deemed ready for trial for purposes of section 30.30 of this chapter untilit has filed a proper certificate pursuant to subdivision one of this section."
Police Officer's Disciplinary Records that Tend to ImpeachMust Be Disclosed
This court has addressed this issue several times since article 245was enacted. Each time, the court has rejected the People's generic assertion that they need notdisclose materials and information underlying substantiated and unsubstantiated disciplinaryfindings.
Criminal Procedure Law § 245.20 (1) (k) (iv) requires that the People disclose:
[a]ll evidence and information, including that which is known to police or otherlaw enforcement agencies acting on the government's behalf in the case, that tends to . . .impeach the credibility of a testifying prosecution witness. . . . Information under this subdivisionshall be disclosed whether or not such information is recorded in tangible [*4]form.
Consistently, this court has held thatthat CPL 245.20 (1) (k) (iv) requires disclosure of records underlying substantiated andunsubstantiated disciplinary allegations of misconduct before a valid COC can be filed (seePeople v Darren, 2022 NY Slip Op 50415(U), 2022 WL 1614380 [Crim Ct, NY County2022]; People v Soto, 72 Misc 3d1153 [Crim Ct, NY County 2021]; People v Williams, 72 Misc 3d 1214[A] [Crim Ct, NY County2021]). Other judges in this courthouse have likewise rejected the People's generic claims in thisregard (see People v Edwards, 74Misc 3d 433 [Crim Ct, NY County 2021 (Weiner, J)]; People v, Barralaga, 73 Misc3d 510 [Crim Ct, NY County 2021 (McDonnell, J)]; People v Kelly, 71 Misc 3d 1202[A] [Crim Ct, NY County 2021(Gaffey, J)]); People v Ahmed Mohammed, CR-026662-21NY [Crim Ct, NY County,Apr. 28, 2022 (Wang, J)]; People v Abdul Salaam, CR-019124-21NY [Crim Ct, NYCounty, Apr. 19, 2022 (Maldonado Cruz, J)]). Courts of other jurisdictions have ruled similarly(see People v Perez, 71 Misc 3d1214[A] [Crim Ct, Bronx County 2021]; People v Herrera, 71 Misc 3d 1205 [A][Dist Ct, Nassau County2021]; People v Cooper, 71 Misc 3d559 [County Ct, Erie County 2021]; People v McKinney, 71 Misc 3d 1221[A] [Crim Ct, Kings County2021]; People v Porter, 71 Misc 3d187 [Crim Ct, Bronx County 2020]; People v Randolph, 69 Misc 3d 770 [Sup Ct, Suffolk County2020]; People v Rosario, 70 Misc3d 753 [Albany County Ct 2020]). Significantly, in Matter of Jayson C (200 AD3d 447, 449 [1st Dept 2021]), the FirstDepartment held, on Equal Protection grounds, that respondents in juvenile proceedings areentitled to the same impeachment material as defendants in criminal cases, and that a meresummary of substantiated allegations is insufficient to comply with CPL 245.20 (1) (k) (iv),"which broadly requires disclosure of all impeachment evidence."
The ability to test — to confront — an adverse witness' credibility throughimpeachment is a fundamental right. Several courts considering the scope of CPL 245.20 (1) (k)have found that there can be a good faith basis to cross-examine police witnesses aboutsubstantiated allegations that are clearly supported by facts — and even as tounsubstantiated allegations when sufficient evidence is available (see People v Kelly, 71 Misc 3d1202[A]; People v Kayjon Yizar, Ind No. 2105/19 [Crim Ct, Bronx County 2021];People v Randolph, 69 Misc 3d770). Indeed, underlying disciplinary records — rather than summaries of thoserecords — may well be necessary to establish a good faith basis for cross-examinationabout specific disciplinary matters.
The People's assertion that they are not required to disclose material and informationunderlying the allegations of the testifying officers' misconduct is not based on the facts orcircumstances of this case. The People do not claim to have encountered any impediments toobtaining the materials at issue here, or that there would have been any difficulty in providingthem to defendant. Nor do the People describe any good faith efforts made to ascertain theexistence of the disciplinary actions or to disclose the materials and information underlying them.The People do not allege that evidence of any particular instance of the testifying officers'substantiated or unsubstantiated misconduct would not tend to impeach those officers' credibilityas witnesses in this case. Rather, in the boilerplate fashion that has been offered time and again,the People claim that they need not disclose any underlying materials and information becausedisciplinary findings are a "collateral issue," not related to the subject matter of the case, unlessthe misconduct occurred in this particular case, and because disclosure "would impose aninsurmountable burden on police departments, prosecutors, and the criminal justice system." ThePeople argue too that dismissal is inappropriate, as their refusal to disclose caused no prejudice.[*5]The People's assertions are of no avail.
The People's claim that disclosure of the underlying materials presents an insurmountableburden on their office is inapposite in this case, which, like most cases in courts of criminaljurisdiction, involves a limited number of police witnesses and a small number of disciplinaryfindings. The People's failure to describe any efforts or difficulty in obtaining records in this caseevidences the minimal burden that might be caused by disclosing disciplinary records here. Tothe contrary, given the summaries included in the DAFs, it is reasonable to assume that thePeople are in actual possession of the documents at issue.[FN2]
Likewise, the People's claim that their COCs should be deemed valid because their failure todisclose the underling materials did not cause prejudice to the defendant is also misplaced.Prejudice is not a factor relating to the validity of a COC (People v Adrovic, 69 Misc 3d 563, 574 [Crim Ct, Kings County2020]). To file a valid COC, the People must be able to state that "after exercising due diligenceand making reasonable inquiries to ascertain the existence of material and information subject todiscovery, they have disclosed and made available all known material and information subject todiscovery" (CPL 245.50 [1]). This is not the case here.
Impeachment evidence concerns the credibility of the officer witness — thetrustworthiness of a witness, whether the witness is believable or whether the witness' history ofbehavior and actions undermine that witness' claims. The Court of Appeals has repeatedly madeclear that impeachment concerns the characteristics of the witness, not the limited subject matterof the crime charged. In People v Walker (83 NY2d 455, 461 [1994]), for instance, theCourt recognized impeachment questioning that "demonstrates an untruthful bent" or "reveals awillingness or disposition . . . voluntarily to place the advancement of . . . individual self-interestahead of principle or of the interests of society." The Court restated that imperative in People v Smith (27 NY3d 652,661 [2016]) and again in People vRouse (34 NY3d 269 [2019]), where impeachment of a testifying officer was atissue.
The People contend that information and material underlying substantiated andunsubstantiated allegations of misconduct against a testifying officer need not be disclosed unlessthe officer's misconduct is directly related to the particular case in which the defendant is beingprosecuted. That is, according to the People, even when substantiated allegations of misconductagainst a testifying officer are numerous, frequent, or severe, and even when those claims revealthe officer's "untruthful bent" and "willingness [and] disposition [to] voluntarily place theadvancement of [the officer's] individual self-interest ahead of principle or of the interests ofsociety," and even though that testimony, at the very least, would "tend to impeach" the testifyingofficer, the People are free to withhold the underlying evidence and information [*6]concerning that misconduct unless it occurred during theinvestigation and prosecution of the very complaint on which the defendant is being prosecuted.That contention is rejected. Limiting CPL article 245 discovery to that rule espoused by thePeople would undermine the purpose and practice of cross-examination affirmed by the Court ofAppeals, as well as the language and purpose of the discovery statute.[FN3]
The ruling urged by the People is particularly unjustifiable in this case, where the People'sDAFs include summaries of serious misconduct bearing on the officers' credibility — asofficers and as witnesses. The DAF for one officer summarizes misconduct substantiated by theNYPD that the officer sent text messages of a personal nature to the girlfriend of a suspect hearrested (including a photograph of himself, stating "so u remember my face" [sic]), and that onanother occasion, the same officer was unfit for duty due to intoxication — which resultedin a physical altercation with other officers. Unsubstantiated charges against that officer concernproperty missing from search warrant premises. The DAF for another officer includessubstantiated findings based on his arrest and misdemeanor conviction for driving whileintoxicated. The evidence of the willingness and disposition of the testifying officers in theseinstances to "voluntarily place the advancement of [their own] individual self-interest ahead ofprinciple or of the interests of society" would certainly — at the very least — tendto impeach their credibility, and would be critical to cross-examination in this case, or any case inwhich these officers would testify. According to the People's argument, however, because theofficers' acts of misconduct were not committed in the context of the instant docket number, thematerials and information underlying these instances of misconduct need not bedisclosed.[FN4]Such a constricted reading of CPL 245 (1) (k) (iv) would critically undermine a defendant's rightto impeach the People's witnesses, so consistently articulated by the Court of Appeals, as well asby article 245 (see People v Edwards, 74 Misc 3d at 440-441; but see People v Florez, 74 Misc 3d1222 [A] [Sup Ct, Nassau County 2022]; People v Hutchins, 2022 NY Slip Op50327 [U], WL 1219631 [Sup Ct, Kings County 2022]).[FN5]Where, as here, a substantiated or unsubstantiated disciplinary [*7]finding against a testifying officer bears on that officer's credibilitysuch that it would tend to impeach the officer's testimony by demonstrating an "untruthful bent"or "willingness [and] disposition [to] voluntarily place the advancement of [the officer's]individual self-interest ahead of principle or of the interests of society," the People must disclosethe materials and information underlying that disciplinary finding in order to file a validCOC.
Finally, the People's contention that dismissal would be an extreme and unwarrantedsanction misconstrues the law. Dismissal pursuant to CPL 30.30 is not a sanction. According toCPL 245.50 (3), the prosecution shall not be deemed ready for trial for purposes of CPL 30.30until a proper COC has been filed (seePeople v Lobato, 66 Misc 3d 1230[A] [Crim Ct, Kings County 2020] ["discoverycompliance is a condition precedent to a valid announcement of readiness for trial, absent'exceptional circumstances' on a particular case"]). The People have not complied with theirdiscovery obligations, and therefore they did not do what was necessary, pursuant to CPL 245and CPL 30.30 to stop the speedy trial clock (see People v Quinlan, 71 Misc 3d 266, 272 [Crim Ct, BronxCounty 2021] [deeming COC invalid and charging the People with speedy trial time "is not an'adverse consequence' as contemplated by CPL 245.80"]). Accordingly, the People have not fileda valid COC and have thus not properly answered ready for trial.
Speedy Trial Calculation
As to defendant's motionto dismiss pursuant to CPL 30.30 (1) (b):
August 18, 2021 to August 23, 2021
Theadjournment for conversion of the complaint to an information is charged to the People. (5 days;5 days total).
August 23, 2021 to October 4, 2021
Theadjournment for trial and discovery compliance is charged to the People. (42 days; 47 daystotal).
October 4, 2021 to November 30, 2021As the Peoplefailed to file a valid COC on October 18, 2021, November 8, 2021, or November 16, 2021, alltime is charged to the People until defendant filed his omnibus motion on November 30, 2021(see CPL 30.30 [4] [a]). (57 days; 104 days total).
November 30, 2021 to January 26, 2022
OnNovember 30, 2021, defendant filed his omnibus motion. That motion was decided on December9, 2021, and the case was adjourned for hearings and trial. This period of motion practice andadjournment for court-ordered hearings is excludable (CPL 30.30 [4] [a]; Matter of People ex rel. LaBrew vVance, 192 AD3d 645 [1st Dept 2021]; People v Green, 90 AD2d 705, 705-706[1st Dept 1982], lv denied, 58 NY2d 784 [1982]; see also People v Davis, 80 AD3d 494, 494-95 [1st Dept 2011]). (0days; 104 days total).
[*8]January 26, 2022 toFebruary 8, 2022
On January 26, 2022, the People were not ready for hearings andtrial and requested February 1, 2022, as a new date. As there had been no valid COC filed, thisentire period is charged to the People. (13 days; 117 days total).
Conclusion
By the court's calculation, the totalincludable speedy trial time amounts to 117 days. As such, the 90-day period in which the Peopleare required to be ready for trial has elapsed. Defendant's motion to dismiss the accusatoryinstrument pursuant to CPL 30.30 (1) (b) is granted.
The foregoing constitutes the opinion, decision, and order of the court.
DATED: June 8, 2022
ENTER
_________________
RobertRosenthal
Judge of the Criminal Court
Footnote 1: All motion papers were timely filed. Through no fault of the parties, they were received by thecourt several weeks late.
Footnote 2:CPL article 245 provides forrelief where discovery disclosure is difficult or untenable. For example, CPL 245.10 (1)(a) allowsfor an extension of time to provide initial discovery where materials are exceptionallyvoluminous. In some circumstances, CPL 245.50 (3) allows for trial readiness when discoverableevidence is unavailable. CPL 245.70 (2) allows for modification of discovery periods for goodcause shown. CPL 245.70 (1) allows for protective orders that might deny, restrict, condition, ordefer disclosure of any discovery. Also, CPL 30.30 (4)(g) allows for exclusion of time chargeableto the People for delay "occasioned by exceptional circumstances." The People here sought nosuch relief.
Footnote 3:People v Garrett (23 NY3d 878,891 [2014]) and its progeny (People vKnight, 69 Misc 3d 546 [Crim Ct, Kings County 2020], People v Sanchez,CR-004739-20NY [Crim Ct, NY County, Feb 10, 2021], and People v Perez, 73 Misc 3d 171 [Sup Ct, Queens County 2021]), onwhich the People rely, limited disclosure to impeachment material related to the subject of theunderlying case. Garrett was decided before the enactment of CPL 245.20 (1)(k)(iv),requiring disclosure of "all evidence and information, including that which is known to police orother law enforcement agencies acting on the government's behalf in the case, that tends to impeach the credibility of a testifying prosecution witness " (CPL 245.20 [1][k][iv]). Thus,Garrett is not applicable here.
Footnote 4:It is conceivable that in no casewould evidence and information concerning the most egregious misconduct be disclosed, if— as the People would have it — discovery requirements were limited to thatwhich is related to the particular crime charged in any given case.
Footnote 5:The conclusion in Florez,that disclosure of material and information underlying substantiated and unsubstantiateddisciplinary allegations is not required, is based entirely on cases decided prior to the enactmentof CPL article 245, which significantly expanded the People's discovery obligations.