Matter of Fatata v Phillips
2016 NY Slip Op 04295 [140 AD3d 1295]
June 2, 2016
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, August 3, 2016


[*1]
 In the Matter of Linda Fatata et al., Appellants, vGeorge Phillips, Respondent, et al., Respondent.

James E. Walsh, Ballston Spa, for appellants.

Hinman, Howard & Kattel LLP, Binghamton (Richard C. Lewis of counsel), forGeorge Phillips, respondent.

Per Curiam. Appeal from an order and judgment of the Supreme Court (Platkin, J.),entered May 16, 2016 in Albany County, which dismissed petitioners' application, in aproceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102, to declare invalid thedesignating petition naming respondent George Phillips as the Republican Partycandidate for the public office of Member of the United States House of Representativesfor the 22nd Congressional District in the June 28, 2016 primary election.

Respondent George Phillips filed a designating petition with respondent New YorkState Board of Elections seeking to be nominated as the Republican Party candidate forthe public office of Member of the United States House of Representatives for the 22ndCongressional District in the June 28, 2016 primary election. Petitioners filed writtenobjections with the Board challenging, as is relevant here, two signatures of thedesignating petition on the basis of candidate fraud (see Election Law§ 6-154 [2]). Shortly thereafter, petitioners commenced this proceedingpursuant to Election Law § 16-102 seeking to invalidate the designatingpetition on the same basis. Phillips answered, and, in the interim, the Board determinedthat the designating petition retained its presumption of validity as the objections raisedallegations of fraud that were beyond the Board's ministerial purview. Supreme Courtthereafter dismissed the petition, finding that petitioners failed to meet their burden ofestablishing that Phillips knowingly engaged in any [*2]fraudulent activity. Petitioners now appeal.

A candidate's designating petition will be invalidated on the basis of fraud onlywhere the challenging party establishes, by clear and convincing evidence, "that theentire petition is permeated with fraud or that the candidate participated in, or can becharged with knowledge of, fraudulent activity" (Matter of VanSavage v Jones, 120 AD3d 887, 888 [2014][internal quotation marks and citations omitted], lv dismissed 23 NY3d 1045[2014], lv denied 24 NY3d 901 [2014]; accord Matter of Mattice v Hammond, 131 AD3d 790, 790[2015]; Matter of Vincent vSira, 131 AD3d 787, 788 [2015], lv denied 25 NY3d 914 [2015]).Petitioners allege that Phillips engaged in fraud when he signed the subscribing witnessstatements on two pages of the petition attesting that each voter who signed his or hername did so in his presence, despite knowing that the statements were false as to twovoters' signatures. Based on these allegations, we agree with Supreme Court that thefinite issue that must be decided is whether petitioners established by clear andconvincing evidence that Phillips participated in or became knowledgeable of any fraudin relation to the subscribing witness statements.[FN1]

The uncontroverted testimony established that Phillips collected the signaturesreflected on pages 17 and 38 of the designating petition. Regarding the signature on line8 of page 17, Phillips testified that the daughter of that voter signed the voter's name afterthe voter informed him that she was physically unable to sign and that her daughterwould sign as her power of attorney. Concerning line 20 of page 38, Phillips similarlytestified that the voter's wife signed her husband's name after she told Phillips that herhusband was incapacitated and could not sign, but that she would sign as his power ofattorney.[FN2]According to Phillips, he thought that "the people signing under a power of attorney hadthe power to act as that person"—including the power to sign the designatingpetition—and, in effect, stepped into the shoes of the person they signed for. Thus,it was Phillips' understanding that a signature by a holder of a power of attorney made inhis presence was the legal equivalent of the incapacitated person's "subscri[ption] to th[e]petition . . . in [his] presence." Phillips testified that, based on this belief, hetruthfully attested in the witness statements that each voter signed his or her name in hispresence and identified himself or herself to be the voter who signed.

Based upon Phillips' undisputed testimony, we find no reason to disturb SupremeCourt's determination. Even assuming that the two signatures at issue are invalid,petitioners failed to establish by clear and convincing evidence that Phillips" 'acted fraudulently or did anything that would warrant invalidating the entiredesignating petition' " (Matter of VanSavage v [*3]Jones, 120 AD3d at 888, quoting Matter of Nolin v McNally, 87AD3d 804, 806 [2011]; seeMatter of Mertz v Bradshaw, 131 AD3d 794, 796 n 2 [2015]; Matter of Felder v Storobin,100 AD3d 11, 16 [2012]; Matter of Kraham v Rabbitt, 11 AD3d 808, 809-810[2004]; Matter of McHugh v Comella, 307 AD2d 1069, 1070 [2003], lvdenied 100 NY2d 509 [2003]). We reject petitioners' contention that our decisions inMatter of Mattice v Hammond (supra) and Matter of Valenti v Bugbee (88AD3d 1056 [2011]) support a contrary conclusion. In both Mattice andValenti, this Court invalidated the designating petitions at issue based upon thecandidates' testimony in which they admitted to signing the witness statements despiteknowing that those statements were materially false (see Matter of Mattice vHammond, 131 AD3d at 791; Matter of Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d at1058). In contrast, there was no similar testimony by Phillips. Accordingly, we find thatSupreme Court properly dismissed the petition.

Peters, P.J., Garry, Rose, Mulvey and Aarons, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order andjudgment is affirmed, without costs.

Footnotes


Footnote 1:Indeed, petitioners donot dispute that Phillips collected significantly more signatures than was required by theElection Law. Thus, even if we were to strike the two signatures at issue, Phillips wouldstill have a sufficient number of signatures absent a finding that those two signatureswere procured by fraud and that Phillips participated in the fraud (see Matter of Mertz vBradshaw, 131 AD3d 794, 796 n 2 [2015]; Matter of Vincent v Sira,131 AD3d at 789; Matter ofBonner v Negron, 87 AD3d 737, 739-740 [2011]).

Footnote 2:According to Phillips, hebelieved that the husband was nearby because the wife "looked to [her husband], shereferenced him and then signed."


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.