Matter of Burman v Subedi
2019 NY Slip Op 04315 [172 AD3d 1882]
May 31, 2019
Appellate Division, Third Department
As corrected through Wednesday, July 3, 2019


[*1]
 In the Matter of Janet Berl Burman et al.,Respondents,
v
Jay Subedi, as Candidate for the Office of Syracuse City Councilor, 1stDistrict, Appellant, et al., Respondents.

Cote & Van Dyke, LLP, Syracuse (Joseph S. Cote III of counsel), for appellant.

Cerio Law Offices, Syracuse (David Herkala of counsel), for Janet Berl Burman and another,respondents.

Per Curiam. Appeal (transferred to this Court by order of the Appellate Division, FourthDepartment) from an order of the Supreme Court (DelConte, J.), entered May 3, 2019 inOnondaga County, which granted petitioners' application, in a proceeding pursuant to ElectionLaw § 16-102, to declare invalid the designating petition naming respondent JaySubedi as the Democratic Party candidate for the public office of Syracuse City Councilor, 1stDistrict in the June 25, 2019 primary election.

Respondent Jay Subedi filed a designating petition with the Onondaga County Board ofElections seeking to be nominated as the Democratic Party candidate for the public office ofSyracuse City Councilor, 1st District in the June 25, 2019 primary election. After petitioner JanetBerl Burman filed general and specific objections to the designating petition, she and petitionerJoseph G. Carni, an aggrieved candidate, commenced this proceeding pursuant to Election Law§ 16-102 alleging, in relevant part, that Subedi committed fraud when he permittedindividuals to sign his designating petition on behalf of other household voters, resulting in 30fraudulent signatures for which Subedi was the subscribing witness. Subedi answered and ahearing ensued, at which petitioners and Subedi stipulated to the relevant facts and the admissionof all hearing exhibits. In a May 2019 order, Supreme Court concluded that Subedi's attestationsas to the 30 challenged signatures were knowingly false and invalidated the entire designatingpetition. Subedi appeals, and the appeal was transferred to this Court from the AppellateDivision, Fourth Department. We affirm.

Where a challenging party establishes by clear and convincing evidence that a candidateparticipated in fraudulent activity, the entire designating petition will be invalidated (see Matter of Mattice v Hammond, 131AD3d 790, 791 [2015]; Matter ofValenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d 1056, 1057 [2011]; Matter of Bynoe v Board ofElections of City of N.Y., 164 AD2d 929, 929-930 [1990], lv denied 76 NY2d 705[1990]). Regarding the challenged signatures for which Subedi was the subscribing witness, it isundisputed that the voters did not subscribe their signatures in Subedi's presence nor did theyidentify themselves to Subedi as the signatories. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Subedi signedthe subscribing witness statement on each sheet containing the challenged signatures and attestedthat, "[e]ach of the individuals whose names are subscribed to this petition sheet . . ., subscribed the same in [his] presence . . . and identified himself or herself to be theindividual who signed [the] sheet." Subedi then filed the designating petition and did not notifythe Board of any irregularity or otherwise correct his subscribing witness statement. Under thesecircumstances, we conclude that Supreme Court correctly determined that there was clear andconvincing evidence of fraudulent conduct on the part of Subedi (see Matter of Buttenschon v Salatino,164 AD3d 1588, 1589 [2018]; Matter of Mattice v Hammond, 131 AD3d at 791;Matter of Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d at 1058; compare Matter of Fatata v Phillips, 140 AD3d 1295, 1295[2016]).

We note that Subedi freely admits his error and contends that he was not trying to gain anyunfair advantage. Fraud, however, does not require any proof of a " 'nefariousmotive' " (Matter of Mattice v Hammond, 131 AD3d at 791, quoting Matterof Valenti v Bugbee, 88 AD3d at 1058). Furthermore, Subedi's argument that he believedthat his attestations regarding the challenged signatures were proper at the time that he filed hisdesignating petition is not supported by the record. Finally, to the extent that Subedi asserts thatonly the sheets containing the fraudulently-procured signatures should be stricken, such assertionis without merit. Given that the record discloses that Subedi participated in the fraudulentactivity, and taking into account that candidates are held to a higher standard than noncandidatesunder the Election Law (see Matter ofFelder v Storobin, 100 AD3d 11, 15 [2012]), we find that invalidation of the entiredesignating petition was warranted (see Matter of Buttenschon v Salatino, 164 AD3d at1589; Matter of Mattice v Hammond, 131 AD3d at 791; Matter of Valenti vBugbee, 88 AD3d at 1057-1058; Matter of Cirillo v Gardiner, 65 AD3d 638, 639 [2009]).

Clark, J.P., Mulvey, Devine, Aarons and Rumsey, JJ., concur. Ordered that the order isaffirmed, without costs.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.