Matter of Frontier Stone, LLC v Town of Shelby
2019 NY Slip Op 05852 [174 AD3d 1382]
July 31, 2019
Appellate Division, Fourth Department
As corrected through Wednesday, September 4, 2019


[*1]
 In the Matter of Frontier Stone, LLC, et al.,Appellants,
v
Town of Shelby et al., Respondents.

Brown Duke & Fogel, P.C., Syracuse (Gregory M. Brown of counsel), forpetitioners-plaintiffs-appellants.

Hodgson Russ LLP, Buffalo (Charles W. Malcomb of counsel), forrespondents-defendants-respondents.

Appeal from a judgment (denominated order and judgment) of the Supreme Court, OrleansCounty (Tracey A. Bannister, J.), entered February 8, 2018, in a CPLR article 78 proceeding anddeclaratory judgment action. The judgment dismissed the petition-complaint in its entirety.

It is hereby ordered that the judgment so appealed from is unanimously modified on the lawby reinstating the petition-complaint to the extent that it seeks a declaration and grantingjudgment in favor of respondents-defendants as follows:

It is adjudged and declared that Local Law No. 3 of 2017 of the Town of Shelby is valid, andas modified the judgment is affirmed without costs.

Memorandum: Petitioners-plaintiffs (petitioners) commenced this hybrid CPLR article 78proceeding and declaratory judgment action seeking, inter alia, to declare invalid Local Law No.3 of 2017 (2017 Law) of respondent-defendant Town of Shelby (Town), which created a wildliferefuge overlay district within the Town, and to annul the negative declaration issued byrespondent-defendant Town Board of Town of Shelby (Town Board) under the StateEnvironmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA) (ECL art 8) with respect to the 2017 Law.Respondents-defendants filed an answer seeking dismissal of the petition-complaint (petition).Following oral argument, Supreme Court dismissed the petition, and petitioners now appeal.

We note at the outset that, inasmuch as petitioners sought declaratory relief, the court erred indismissing the petition without declaring the rights of the parties (see generally Restuccio v City ofOswego, 114 AD3d 1191, 1191 [4th Dept 2014]), and we therefore modify the judgmentaccordingly. We otherwise affirm.

In March 2006, petitioner-plaintiff Frontier Stone, LLC applied for a mining permit for aproposed stone quarry in an agricultural/residential (AR) zoning district in the Town. Shortlythereafter, the Town Board adopted a moratorium on processing special permit applications formining and excavation projects. The Town Board then adopted Local Law No. 5 of 2007 (2007Law), which effectively removed excavation and mining from the list of conditional uses in theTown's AR zoning district. The 2007 Law also provided that certain large mining operationscould occur only: (1) in a newly formed mining/excavation (ME) overlay district; (2) with aspecial use permit; (3) within an industrial district; and (4) pursuant to an approved site plan.

Later, the Town Board proposed Local Law No. 2 of 2016 (2016 Law), which would create awildlife refuge overlay district (overlay district) covering both the Iroquois National WildlifeRefuge (INWR) and a buffer area of nearby land that included the land on which the project siteis located, and which would prohibit mining and excavation therein. The proposed 2016 Law wasnot adopted but, on June 19, 2017, the Town Board issued a negative declaration for a proposednew law, i.e., the 2017 Law. In issuing the negative declaration, the Town Board determined thatthe 2017 Law would not have a significant adverse environmental impact. The 2017 Lawproposed to amend the 2016 Law "to limit the impact area necessary to protect the refuge byreducing the size of the buffer from 3000 to 2000 feet." The buffer area, however, still includedthe land on which the project site is located. The Town Board adopted the 2017 Law, whichdefined the overlay district as including the INWR and the reduced buffer area, and whichprohibited mining within the overlay district.

Petitioners initially contend that the 2017 Law conflicts with the Town's comprehensive plan,and thus the Town Board lacked authority to adopt it. We reject that contention. " 'If thevalidity of the legislative classification for zoning purposes [is] fairly debatable, the legislativejudgment must be allowed to control . . . Thus, where the [parties challenging thezoning classification] fail[ ] to establish a clear conflict with the comprehensive plan, the zoningclassification must be upheld' " (Matter of Ferraro v Town Bd. of Town of Amherst, 79 AD3d 1691,1694 [4th Dept 2010], lv denied 16 NY3d 711 [2011]; see Restuccio, 114 AD3dat 1191-1192; Bergstol v Town ofMonroe, 15 AD3d 324, 325 [2d Dept 2005], lv denied 5 NY3d 701 [2005]).Here, the 2007 Law, which the parties agree was made part of the Town's comprehensive plan,effectively banned mining in the AR district in which the project site is located. Moreover, noindustrial zones were present within the overlay district created by the 2017 Law. Thus, weconclude that petitioners failed to establish a clear conflict between the 2017 Law and the Town'scomprehensive plan.

Contrary to petitioners' further contention, we conclude that, in issuing its negativedeclaration, the Town Board properly "identified the relevant areas of environmental concern asrelated to the proposed action, took the requisite 'hard look' at them and . . . set fortha reasoned elaboration of the basis for its determination" (Matter of Gernatt Asphalt Prods. vTown of Sardinia, 87 NY2d 668, 689-690 [1996]; see Matter of Wells v Board of Trustees of Inc. Vil. of Northport, 40AD3d 652, 653 [2d Dept 2007]). In particular, the Town Board made specific findings aboutthe need to preserve and protect the INWR and its unique wildlife habitat, and the Town Boardclarified that the new overlay district would not authorize any development, but would ratherrestrict land uses to protect the environment. Moreover, the record reflects that the Town Boardconsidered the potential effects of the 2017 Law and rationally concluded that the law wouldhave no significant adverse environmental impacts. Although petitioners contend that the TownBoard erred by failing to take into consideration the potential beneficial impact of their proposedquarry on water levels in the overlay district, especially in light of the presumed effects ofclimate change, we reject that contention. The Town Board had the discretion to select theenvironmental impacts most relevant to its determination and to overlook those "of doubtfulrelevance" (Matter of Save the PineBush, Inc. v Common Council of City of Albany, 13 NY3d 297, 308 [2009]; seeMatter of Jackson v New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417 [1986]; Matter of Gabrielli v Town of NewPaltz, 116 AD3d 1315, 1318 [3d Dept 2014]).

We further reject petitioners' contention that the 2017 Law is preempted by the New YorkState Mined Land Reclamation Law (MLRL) (ECL 23-2701 et seq.). "[T]he MLRL doesnot preempt [a] [t]own's authority to determine that mining should not be a permitted use of landwithin the [t]own, and to enact amendments to the local zoning ordinance in accordance with thatdetermination" (Gernatt Asphalt Prods., 87 NY2d at 683). However, "[w]hile a localityretains general authority to regulate land use, and has the authority to determine that mining willnot be a use within its confines, it may not regulate the specifics of the extractive mining orreclamation process" (Philipstown Indus. Park v Town Bd. of Town of Philipstown, 247AD2d 525, 527-528 [2d Dept 1998]). Here, because the 2017 Law prohibits mining in a certainportion of the Town and does not affect the process or method of mining, it is not preempted bythe MLRL.

Petitioners additionally contend that the Town's determination enacting the 2017 Law mustbe annulled because the Town failed to comply with lawful procedure. We reject that contention.Initially, inasmuch as the 2017 Law was enacted pursuant to the Municipal Home Rule Law, theprocedural requirements of the Town Law do not apply to its enactment (see Matter ofDalrymple Gravel & Contr. Co. v Town of Erwin, 305 AD2d 1036, 1037 [4th Dept2003]). Petitioners' contention that the Town's Zoning Code (Code) requires notice to adjoiningcounties was raised for the first time in their reply brief and is therefore not properly before us(see O'Sullivan v O'Sullivan, 206 AD2d 960, 960-961 [4th Dept 1994]). Furthermore, weconclude that, under the circumstances, the Town Board satisfied the applicable requirements inthe Municipal Home Rule Law and the Code regarding the holding of a public hearing andreferral to respondent-defendant Town of Shelby Planning Board (Planning Board) (seeMunicipal Home Rule Law § 20 [5]; Code § 112 [C]) through thepublic hearing and Planning Board referral carried out in connection with the proposed 2016 Law(see Gernatt Asphalt Prods., 87 NY2d at 678-679; Matter of Benson Point Realty Corp. v Town of E. Hampton, 62 AD3d989, 991-992 [2d Dept 2009], lv dismissed 13 NY3d 788 [2009]). The changesbetween the proposed 2016 Law and the 2017 Law were minor and did not result in asubstantially different law or one that was not "embraced within the [prior] public notice"(Gernatt Asphalt Prods., 87 NY2d at 679; see Lighthouse Shores v Town of Islip,41 NY2d 7, 10-11 [1976]; Benson Point Realty Corp., 62 AD3d at 991; Caruso vTown of Oyster Bay, 250 AD2d 639, 640 [2d Dept 1998]; cf. Matter of Calverton Manor, LLC vTown of Riverhead, 160 AD3d 842, 844-845 [2d Dept 2018]), and the Planning Boardwas "clearly notified" of the effect of the proposed 2016 Law (Gernatt Asphalt Prods., 87NY2d at 680).

We have reviewed petitioners' remaining contentions and conclude that none requires furthermodification or reversal of the judgment. Present—Whalen, P.J., Peradotto, Lindley,DeJoseph and NeMoyer, JJ.


NYPTI Decisions © 2026 is a project of New York Prosecutors Training Institute (NYPTI) made possible by leveraging the work we've done providing online research and tools to prosecutors.

NYPTI would like to thank New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, New York State Senate's Open Legislation Project, New York State Unified Court System, New York State Law Reporting Bureau and Free Law Project for their invaluable assistance making this project possible.

Install the free RECAP extensions to help contribute to this archive. See https://free.law/recap/ for more information.