| Matter of Gans v New York State Tax Appeals Trib. |
| 2021 NY Slip Op 03089 [194 AD3d 1209] |
| May 13, 2021 |
| Appellate Division, Third Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Robert Gans, Petitioner, v New YorkState Tax Appeals Tribunal et al., Respondents. |
Kostelanetz & Fink, LLP, New York City (Kevin M. Flynn of counsel), forpetitioner.
Letitia James, Attorney General, Albany (Frederick A. Brodie of counsel), for Commissionerof Taxation and Finance, respondent.
Garry, P.J. Proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 (initiated in this Court pursuant to TaxLaw § 2016) to review a determination of respondent Tax Appeals Tribunalsustaining a sales and use tax assessment imposed under Tax Law articles 28 and 29.
Petitioner serves as managing member of The Executive Club LLC, which operates an adultentertainment establishment (hereinafter the club) in Manhattan, and is a person responsible forthat entity's payment of taxes. After guests paid an entry fee using either cash or credit card, theywere able to view live performances in the main area of the club or utilize the bar or restaurant.To enter the club's private rooms, guests were required to pay a room charge by check, cash orcredit card, and a separate performance fee to the entertainer, either by cash or scrip. Scrip is theclub's own in-house currency that can be purchased by credit card, with a 20% surchargeimposed, which may then be used as payment of performance fees or gratuities for entertainers orfor club employees such as bartenders and hosts. When exchanging the scrip for another form ofpayment, the club charged the entertainer a 13% redemption fee.
After an audit of the club's sales and use taxes for certain periods from 2010 to 2013, theDepartment of Taxation and Finance issued notices of determination asserting tax deficienciesagainst petitioner due to the club's failure to assess taxes on, among other things, the purchase ofscrip. Following a hearing on petitioner's challenge to those notices, an Administrative LawJudge (hereinafter ALJ) sustained the notices, finding that the sale of scrip was taxable.Respondent Tax Appeals Tribunal denied petitioner's exceptions and affirmed the ALJ'sdetermination. Petitioner then commenced this CPLR article 78 proceeding challenging theTribunal's determination.
"[T]ax statutes should be construed to insure the collection of all designated taxes where asupportable theory can be found" (Matter of 1605 Book Ctr. v Tax Appeals Trib. of State ofN.Y., 83 NY2d 240, 244 [1994], cert denied 513 US 811 [1994]). "[I]n cases where,as here, the issues argued before the Tribunal involved the specific application of broad statutoryterms in a proceeding in which the agency administering the statute must determine it initially,"this Court "accord[s] deference to the Tribunal's interpretation of the statutes at issue" and "willnot disturb the Tribunal's determination if it has a rational basis and is supported by substantialevidence" (Matter of HDV Manhattan,LLC v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 156 AD3d 963, 965 [2017] [internalquotation marks, ellipsis, brackets and citations omitted]; see Matter of CLM Assoc., LLC v New York State Tax Appeals Trib.,181 AD3d 999, 1001 [2020], lv denied 36 NY3d 904 [2021]; Matter of Prima Asphalt Concrete, Inc. vNew York State Tax Appeals Trib., 162 AD3d 1281, 1282 [2018], lv denied 32NY3d 914 [2019]). Credibility determinations lie within the province [*2]of the administrative factfinder (see Matter of 677 New Loudon Corp. v State of N.Y. Tax AppealsTrib., 85 AD3d 1341, 1345 [2011], affd 19 NY3d 1058 [2012], certdenied 571 US 952 [2013]).
Tax Law § 1105 requires the payment of sales tax on, among other things andwith exceptions not relevant here, "[t]he receipts from every retail sale of tangible personalproperty" (Tax Law § 1105 [a]), "[a]ny admission charge . . . for theuse of any place of amusement" (Tax Law § 1105 [f] [1]), and "[t]he amount paid ascharges of a roof garden, cabaret or other similar place" (Tax Law § 1105 [f] [3]).As used in that statute, an admission charge is not limited to its common meaning of the price ofentry, but is defined as "[t]he amount paid for admission, including any service charge and anycharge for entertainment or amusement or for the use of facilities therefor" (Tax Law§ 1101 [d] [2]). "Place of amusement" is defined as "[a]ny place where any facilitiesfor entertainment, amusement, or sports are provided" (Tax Law § 1101 [d] [10])."Roof garden, cabaret or other similar place" is defined as "[a]ny roof garden, cabaret or othersimilar place which furnishes a public performance for profit," with certain exceptions (Tax Law§ 1101 [d] [12]), and "[c]harge of a roof garden, cabaret or other similar place" isdefined as "[a]ny charge made for admission, refreshment, service, or merchandise at a roofgarden, cabaret or other similar place" (Tax Law § 1101 [d] [4]; see 20NYCRR 527.12 [b]). Further, "it shall be presumed that all receipts for . . . allamusement charges of any type mentioned in [Tax Law § 1105 (f)] are subject totax until the contrary is established, and the burden of proving that any . . .amusement charge . . . is not taxable [t]hereunder shall be upon the person requiredto collect tax" (Tax Law § 1132 [c] [1]; accord Matter of HDV Manhattan, LLCv Tax Appeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 156 AD3d at 965).
Although we agree with petitioner that scrip is not tangible personal property, the Tribunalrationally concluded that it also is not intangible personal property similar to gift cards (seeMatter of Executive Club LLC, 2017 WL 1656454, *10, 2017 NY Tax LEXIS 63, *26-28[Tax Appeals Trib., DTA No. 825850, Apr. 19, 2017]).[FN*] This Court has previously found that adultentertainment clubs, such as that operated by petitioner, constitute "a cabaret or other similarplace" and, "given that charges of a cabaret or other similar place include service andentertainment charges, the revenue generated from the sale of scrip—which could be usedto tip or purchase table dances and/or private dances—is properly taxable under Tax Law§ 1105 (f) (3)" (Matter of HDV Manhattan, LLC v Tax Appeals Trib. of theState of N.Y., 156 AD3d at 969-970 [internal quotation marks, ellipsis and citationsomitted]; see Metro Enters. Corp. v NewYork State Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 171 AD3d 1377, 1380 [2019]; cf. Matterof 1605 Book Ctr. v Tax Appeals Trib. [*3]of State of N.Y.,83 NY2d at 244-245; Matter of 677 New Loudon Corp. v State of N.Y. Tax AppealsTrib., 85 AD3d at 1346). Similarly, "[w]e find no basis to disturb the Tribunal'sdetermination that the club's receipts from the sale of scrip are taxable as admission charges to aplace of amusement" (Matter of HDV Manhattan, LLC v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State ofN.Y., 156 AD3d at 965). Considering our prior holdings, and the statutory presumption thatthe sale of scrip was taxable (see Tax Law § 1132 [c] [1]), we conclude thatpetitioner failed to meet his "burden of proving the contrary by clear and convincing evidence"(Matter of CLM Assoc., LLC v New York State Tax Appeals Trib., 181 AD3d at 1000;cf. Metro Enters. Corp. v New York State Dept. of Taxation & Fin., 171 AD3d at1380).
Although petitioner established that customers used scrip to provide entertainers withtips—and amounts given in tips may not be subject to sales tax—the Tribunalagreed with the ALJ's conclusions that petitioner "failed to meet [his] burden of proving theamount of tips based upon the scarcity of the records petitioner[ ] submitted into evidence, theunconvincing nature of such records, and in certain instances, the contradictory nature of theevidence." Having conducted our own review of the evidence submitted by petitioner, and givingdeference to the Tribunal's credibility determinations, we agree that petitioner "failed to establishthe amount of scrip sold that was attributable to [tips]. In the absence of such evidence, we willnot disturb the Tribunal's determination that all scrip sales were presumptively taxable"(Matter of HDV Manhattan, LLC v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 156 AD3d at966, citing Tax Law § 1132 [c] [1]; see Matter of Hwang v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 105AD3d 1151, 1152 [2013]).
Upon review, the Tribunal may remand a case for additional proceedings before the ALJ(see Tax Law § 2006 [7]; 20 NYCRR 3000.17 [e] [2]; see generallyMatter of Upstate Farms Coop. v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 290 AD2d 896, 901[2002]). During the hearing, although petitioner noted that the club maintained records for eachday of operation that would support the record evidence and testimony of its employees, thattestimony and the submitted documents addressed the use of scrip for tips on only a few selecteddates from the multi-year period at issue. At the close of the hearing, the ALJ advised the partiesthat the record would be closed unless a party identified a specific document that would beproduced. After further discussion, the ALJ stated that the record did not include a "completesubstantiation" as petitioner failed to establish the total amount of scrip that was used for tipsduring the audit period. Despite these warnings, petitioner withdrew his request to leave therecord open. Accordingly, the Tribunal rationally concluded that remand to the ALJ for furtherproof of the amount of scrip used for tips was [*4]not warranted(see Matter of Reeves v Tax AppealsTrib. of State of N.Y., 34 AD3d 1024, 1025-1026 [2006]; compare Matter of New Cingular WirelessPCS, LLC v Tax Appeals Trib. of the State of N.Y., 153 AD3d 976, 979-980 [2017];Matter of Upstate Farms Coop. v Tax Appeals Trib. of State of N.Y., 290 AD2d at901).
Lynch, Clark, Pritzker and Colangelo, JJ., concur. Adjudged that the determination isconfirmed, without costs, and petition dismissed.
Footnote *:For example, the six-monthexpiration associated with the use of the club's scrip would be prohibited by federal law if it was,in fact, legally equivalent to a gift card (see 15 USC § 1693l-1 [b][1]).