| Matter of Monto v Zeigler |
| 2020 NY Slip Op 02753 [183 AD3d 1294] |
| May 13, 2020<> |
| Appellate Division, Fourth Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of James J. Monto, III,Respondent-Appellant, v Jason B. Zeigler, Appellant-Respondent, et al.,Respondent. |
Joseph T. Burns, Williamsville, for respondent-appellant-respondent and Jason B.Zeigler, respondent-appellant-respondent pro se.
Cote & Vandyke, LLP, Syracuse (Joseph S. Cote, III, of counsel), forpetitioner-respondent-appellant.
Appeal and cross appeal from an order of the Supreme Court, Onondaga County(Joseph E. Lamendola, J.), entered May 5, 2020, in a proceeding pursuant to ElectionLaw article 16. The order granted the petition to invalidate the designating petition ofrespondent Jason B. Zeigler.
It is hereby ordered that said cross appeal is unanimously dismissed, the order isreversed on the law without costs, and the petition is dismissed.
Memorandum: In this proceeding pursuant to Election Law § 16-102,Jason B. Zeigler (respondent) appeals and petitioner cross-appeals from an order that,inter alia, invalidated a designating petition to place respondent on the primary electionballot for the Democratic Party as a candidate for Syracuse City Court Judge.Preliminarily, we reject respondent's contention on appeal that the proceeding wasuntimely commenced (seegenerally Matter of Parietti v Sampson, 117 AD3d 830, 832, 834-835 [2d Dept2014]).
We agree with respondent, however, that Supreme Court erred in invalidating hisdesignating petition after concluding that he had personally participated in fraudulentactivity, which must be established by clear and convincing evidence (see Matter of Burman vSubedi, 172 AD3d 1882, 1883 [3d Dept 2019], lv denied 33 NY3d 906[2019]; Matter of Duck vMannion, 164 AD3d 1103, 1104 [4th Dept 2018], lv denied 31 NY3d914 [2018]). That standard requires evidence that "makes it highly probable that what [aparty] claims is what actually happened" (PJI 1:64), i.e., evidence " 'that isneither equivocal nor open to opposing presumptions' " (Matter of Seon v New York StateDept. of Motor Vehs., 159 AD3d 607, 613 [1st Dept 2018]), and it "forbidsrelief whenever the evidence is loose, equivocal or contradictory" (George BackerMgt. Corp. v Acme Quilting Co., 46 NY2d 211, 220 [1978] [internal quotationmarks omitted]). Here, the court based its determination to invalidate the designatingpetition on the testimony of a single signatory, who stated that although respondent wasthe subscribing witness on the petition that she signed, her signature was actuallywitnessed by a younger man of a different race. While such evidence may warrantinvalidation of a designating petition (see Matter of Haskell v Gargiulo, 51 NY2d747, 748 [1980]; Matter ofMattice v Hammond, 131 AD3d 790, 790-791 [3d Dept 2015]),cross-examination of the signatory—during which she acknowledged signing fourCity Court petitions, including one for an individual whose description was similar tothat of respondent—called her testimony on direct examination into question.Even granting due deference to the court's assessment of witness credibility (seegenerally Matter of Farrell v Cayuga County Bd. of Elections, 288 AD2d 844, 844[4th Dept 2001]), we cannot conclude that the signatory's equivocal andself-contradictory testimony constituted clear and convincing evidence that respondentengaged in fraud (see George Backer Mgt. Corp., 46 NY2d at 220).
Petitioner's cross appeal must be dismissed on the ground that he is not aggrieved bythe order (see Matter ofGiordano v Westchester County Bd. of Elections, 153 AD3d 821, 823 [2d Dept2017], lv denied 29 NY3d 915 [2017]; see generally National Fuel Gas Distrib. Corp. v Push Buffalo[People United for Sustainable Hous.], 104 AD3d 1307, 1308 [4th Dept 2013]).Although his contentions can still be considered as alternative grounds for affirmance onrespondent's appeal (see Parochial Bus Sys. v Board of Educ. of City of N.Y., 60NY2d 539, 545-546 [1983]; Giordano, 153 AD3d at 823), we conclude thatrespondent's apparent failure to administer to one signatory "an oath . . .'calculated to awaken the conscience and impress the mind of the person taking it inaccordance with his religious or ethical beliefs' " (Matter of Bonner v Negron, 87AD3d 737, 738 [2d Dept 2011], quoting CPLR 2309 [b]) did not, on its own,constitute evidence of fraud requiring invalidation of his designating petition (see Matter of Vincent v Sira,131 AD3d 787, 788-789 [3d Dept 2015], lv denied 25 NY3d 914 [2015];Bonner, 87 AD3d at 739-740; Matter of Nolin v McNally, 87 AD3d 804, 805-806 [3dDept 2011]). On the whole, the hearing testimony established that the subscribingwitnesses, including respondent, substantially complied with the requirements ofElection Law § 6-132 (3) (see Matter of Dwyer v Pellegrino, 164 AD3d 1088, 1089[3d Dept 2018]; Matter of Finnv Sherwood, 87 AD3d 1044, 1045 [2d Dept 2011]). We therefore reverse theorder and dismiss the petition. Present—Whalen, P.J., Smith, Peradotto andBannister, JJ.