| Matter of Youngewirth v Town of Ramapo Town Bd. |
| 2017 NY Slip Op 07744 [155 AD3d 755] |
| November 8, 2017 |
| Appellate Division, Second Department |
[*1]
| In the Matter of Elizabeth Youngewirth,Appellant, v Town of Ramapo Town Board et al.,Respondents. |
Bruce M. Levine, Montebello, NY, for appellant.
Michael L. Klein, Town Attorney, Suffern, NY (Janice Gittelman and Michael Specht ofcounsel), for respondents Town of Ramapo Town Board and Town of Ramapo.
Rice & Amon, Suffern, NY (Terry Rice of counsel), for respondent ScenicDevelopment, LLC.
In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to review three determinations of the Town ofRamapo Town Board, all dated January 25, 2010, resolving to approve a findings statementpursuant to the State Environmental Quality Review Act (ECL article 8) in connection with aproposed development project, to amend the Comprehensive Plan of the Town of Ramapo so asto permit the development project, and to rezone the real property on which the developmentproject is proposed to be constructed, respectively, the petitioner appeals from a judgment of theSupreme Court, Rockland County (Walsh II, J.), dated May 8, 2013, which denied the petitionand dismissed the proceeding.
Ordered that the judgment is reversed, on the law, with one bill of costs payable by therespondents appearing separately and filing separate briefs, the petition is granted, thedeterminations of the Town of Ramapo Town Board are annulled, and the matter is remitted tothe Town of Ramapo Town Board for further proceedings consistent herewith.
In 2009, the respondent Scenic Development, LLC (hereinafter Scenic), sought a zonechange for a portion of a parcel of real property it owned in the Town of Ramapo (hereinafter thesubject property) to permit the development of multifamily units. In three determinations, alldated January 25, 2010, the Town of Ramapo Town Board (hereinafter the Town Board)resolved to (1) approve a findings statement pursuant to the State Environmental Quality ReviewAct (ECL art 8 [hereinafter SEQRA]) for the proposed zone change, (2) amend theComprehensive Plan of the Town of Ramapo so as to permit the zone change, and (3) grant thezone change subject to specified conditions, respectively. The petitioner commenced thisproceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78 to annul the Town Board's determinations. The TownBoard and the Town of Ramapo (hereinafter together the Town), and Scenic separately moved todismiss the proceeding, inter alia, pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (3) on the ground that the petitionerlacked standing. The Supreme Court granted the [*2]respondents'motions, finding that the petitioner lacked standing. The petitioner appealed to this Court, andthis Court concluded that the petitioner had standing with respect to several causes of action, andremitted the matter to the Supreme Court, Rockland County, for a determination of those causesof action on the merits (see Matter ofYoungewirth v Town of Ramapo Town Bd., 98 AD3d 678, 680 [2012]).
In a judgment dated May 8, 2013, the Supreme Court addressed those causes of action on themerits, denied the petition, and dismissed the proceeding. The petitioner appeals, and wereverse.
" '[I]n a proceeding seeking judicial review of administrative action, the court maynot substitute its judgment for that of the agency responsible for making the determination, butmust ascertain only whether there is a rational basis for the decision or whether it is arbitrary andcapricious' " (Matter ofFogelman v New York State Dept. of Envtl. Conservation, 74 AD3d 809, 810 [2010],quoting Flacke v Onondaga Landfill Sys., 69 NY2d 355, 363 [1987]; see Matter of Suffolk County Assn. ofMun. Empls., Inc. v Levy, 133 AD3d 676, 677 [2015]; Matter of Gracie Point Community Councilv New York State Dept. of Envtl. Conservation, 92 AD3d 123, 128 [2011]; Matter of 508 Realty Assoc., LLC v NewYork State Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal, 61 AD3d 753, 754-755 [2009]).This is true even where the court would have reached a different result (see Matter of Terrace Ct., LLC v New YorkState Div. of Hous. & Community Renewal, 18 NY3d 446, 454 [2012]; Matter of Deerpark Farms, LLC vAgricultural & Farmland Protection Bd. of Orange County, 70 AD3d 1037, 1038[2010]). "An action is arbitrary and capricious when it is taken without sound basis in reason orregard to the facts" (Matter of Deerpark Farms, LLC v Agricultural & FarmlandProtection Bd. of Orange County, 70 AD3d at 1038; see Matter of Pell v Board of Educ.of Union Free School Dist. No. 1 of Towns of Scarsdale & Mamaroneck, WestchesterCounty, 34 NY2d 222, 231 [1974]).
"Judicial review of an agency determination under SEQRA is limited to whether the agencyprocedures were lawful and whether the agency identified the relevant areas of environmentalconcern, took a hard look at them, and made a reasoned elaboration of the basis for itsdetermination" (Matter of Village ofKiryas Joel, N.Y. v Village of Woodbury, N.Y., 138 AD3d 1008, 1011-1012 [2016][internal quotation marks omitted]; seeMatter of Bronx Comm. for Toxic Free Schs. v New York City Sch. Constr. Auth., 20 NY3d148, 155 [2012]; Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d 561, 570 [1990]; Matter of Jackson vNew York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d 400, 417 [1986]; Matter of DeFeo v Zoning Bd. of Appealsof Town of Bedford, 137 AD3d 1123, 1127 [2016]; Matter of Saint James Antiochian Orthodox Church v Town of Hyde ParkPlanning Bd., 132 AD3d 687 [2015]; Matter of Falcon Group Ltd. Liab. Co. v Town/Village of Harrison PlanningBd., 131 AD3d 1237, 1239 [2015]; Matter of Village of Chestnut Ridge v Town of Ramapo, 99 AD3d918, 925 [2012]). "[A]n agency, acting as a rational decision maker, must have conducted aninvestigation and reasonably exercised its discretion so as to make a reasoned elaboration as tothe effect of a proposed action on a particular environmental concern" (Akpan v Koch, 75NY2d at 571). However, " '[i]n a statutory scheme whose purpose is that the agencydecision-makers focus attention on environmental concerns, it is not the role of the courts toweigh the desirability of any action or choose among alternatives, but to assure that the agencyitself has satisfied SEQRA, procedurally and substantively' " (Matter of Village ofKiryas Joel, N.Y. v Village of Woodbury, N.Y., 138 AD3d at 1012, quoting Matter ofJackson v New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 NY2d at 416; see Akpan v Koch,75 NY2d at 571; Matter of Saint James Antiochian Orthodox Church v Town of Hyde ParkPlanning Bd., 132 AD3d at 687-688; Matter of Village of Chestnut Ridge v Town ofRamapo, 99 AD3d at 925).
Here, we agree with the petitioner's contention that the Town Board failed to take a "hardlook" at the environmental impact of placing the proposed development in close proximity to theexisting Columbia Gas pipeline, and the combined environmental impact of the pipeline and thedevelopment together. The Draft Environmental Impact Statement (hereinafter DEIS) containsonly a brief mention of the pipeline which bisects the property, and Columbia Gas was omittedfrom the list of "interested agencies." In addition, there is nothing in the Town Board'sdeterminations that suggests that it considered these issues outside the context of the DEIS andthe final environmental impact statement (hereinafter FEIS), and they are not discussed in theTown's SEQRA findings statement. Thus, the record supports the petitioner's contention that theTown Board did not take a "hard look" at these issues or make a "reasoned elaboration" of thebasis for its determination [*3]regarding them (see Matter ofBronx Comm. for Toxic Free Schs. v New York City Sch. Constr. Auth., 20 NY3d at 155;Akpan v Koch, 75 NY2d at 570; Matter of Jackson v New York State Urban Dev.Corp., 67 NY2d at 417; Matter of Village of Kiryas Joel, N.Y. v Village of Woodbury,N.Y., 138 AD3d at 1011-1012; Matter of DeFeo v Zoning Bd. of Appeals of Town ofBedford, 137 AD3d at 1127; Matter of Saint James Antiochian Orthodox Church v Townof Hyde Park Planning Bd., 132 AD3d at 687; Matter of Falcon Group Ltd. Liab. Co. vTown/Village of Harrison Planning Bd., 131 AD3d at 1239; Matter of Village ofChestnut Ridge v Town of Ramapo, 99 AD3d at 925), and the Supreme Court should haveannulled the Town Board's determination resolving to approve the findings statement pursuant toSEQRA for the proposed zone change.
Turning to the petitioner's contentions regarding the Comprehensive Plan and the proposedzoning change determinations, "[t]he power to zone is derived from the Legislature and must beexercised in the case of towns and villages in accord with a 'comprehensive plan' " (Nicholson v Incorporated Vil. of GardenCity, 112 AD3d 893, 894 [2013] [internal quotation marks omitted], quoting AsianAms. for Equality v Koch, 72 NY2d 121, 131 [1988]; see Town Law§ 263; Matter ofBirchwood Neighborhood Assn. v Planning Bd. of the Town of Colonie, 112 AD3d1184, 1185 [2013]; Matter ofBergami v Town Bd. of the Town of Rotterdam, 97 AD3d 1018, 1019 [2012]). "Thefunction of land regulation is to implement a plan for the future development of the community"(Nicholson v Incorporated Vil. of Garden City, 112 AD3d at 894; see Berenson vTown of New Castle, 38 NY2d 102, 109 [1975]).
" 'As legislative acts, zoning ordinances carry a presumption ofconstitutionality. . . . [T]his presumption is rebuttable, but . . .unconstitutionality must be demonstrated beyond a reasonable doubt' " (Matter ofVillage of Kiryas Joel, N.Y. v Village of Woodbury, N.Y., 138 AD3d at 1013, quotingRobert E. Kurzius, Inc. v Incorporated Vil. of Upper Brookville, 51 NY2d 338, 344[1980]; see Matter of Birchwood Neighborhood Assn. v Planning Bd. of the Town ofColonie, 112 AD3d at 1185; Matter of Bergami v Town Bd. of the Town ofRotterdam, 97 AD3d at 1019; Matter of Rotterdam Ventures, Inc. v Town Bd. of the Town ofRotterdam, 90 AD3d 1360, 1361-1362 [2011]). "A party challenging the determinationof a local governmental board bears the heavy burden of showing that the target regulation is notjustified under the police power of the state by any reasonable interpretation of the facts" (Matter of Hart v Town Bd. of Town ofHuntington, 114 AD3d 680, 683 [2014] [internal quotation marks omitted]). "If thevalidity of the legislative classification for zoning purposes is even 'fairly debatable,' it must besustained upon judicial review" (id. at 683, quoting Matter of Town of Bedford vVillage of Mount Kisco, 33 NY2d 178, 186 [1973], and Taylor v Incorporated Vil. ofHead of Harbor, 104 AD2d 642, 645 [1984]). " 'Thus, when a plaintiff fails toestablish a clear conflict with the comprehensive plan, the zoning classification must beupheld' " (Matter of Hart v Town Bd. of Town of Huntington, 114 AD3d at 683,quoting Infinity Consulting Group, Inc.v Town of Huntington, 49 AD3d 813, 814 [2008]; see Nicholson v Incorporated Vil.of Garden City, 112 AD3d at 894). " '[T]he responsibility for making zoningdecisions has been committed primarily to quasi-legislative, quasi-administrative boardscomposed of representatives from the local community. Local officials, generally, possess thefamiliarity with local conditions necessary to make the often sensitive planning decisions whichaffect the development of their community. Absent arbitrariness, it is for locally selected andlocally responsible officials to determine where the public interest in zoning lies' " (Matter of Pecoraro v Board of Appeals ofTown of Hempstead, 2 NY3d 608, 613 [2004], quoting Matter of Cowan v Kern,41 NY2d 591, 599 [1977]).
" 'The judicial responsibility is to review zoning decisions but not, absent proof ofarbitrary and unreasonable action, to make them' " (Matter of Pecoraro v Board ofAppeals of Town of Hempstead, 2 NY3d at 613, quoting Matter of Cowan v Kern,41 NY2d at 599; see Matter of Kaiser vTown of Islip Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 74 AD3d 1203, 1204 [2010]; Matter of Merlotto v Town of PattersonZoning Bd. of Appeals, 43 AD3d 926, 928 [2007]). Thus, where the record does notindicate that the agency charged with authority over zoning has "acted in a manner that was inany way arbitrary, unreasonable, irrational or indicative of bad faith," its determination shouldnot be disturbed (Matter of Cowan v Kern, 41 NY2d at 599). "[I]n reviewing whether azoning change is contrary to a town's comprehensive plan, we must ultimately consider, amongother things, whether the change 'conflict[s] with the fundamental land use policies anddevelopment plans of the community' " (Matter of Bergami v Town Bd. of the Townof Rotterdam, 97 AD3d at 1020, quoting Matter of [*4]Gernatt Asphalt Prods. v Town of Sardinia, 87 NY2d 668, 685[1996]; see Matter of Rotterdam Ventures, Inc. v Town Bd. of the Town of Rotterdam,90 AD3d at 1362).
Here, as the petitioner points out, the subject property was not included among the list ofthose deemed "particularly suitable" for multi-family development in the Town's ComprehensivePlan. However, the Comprehensive Plan stated that it was "likely that there may be other sitesthat meet the above placement criteria that [had] not been specifically identified." Since theTown Board left itself this latitude to identify additional areas in the future, the petitioner did not" 'establish a clear conflict with the comprehensive plan' " (Matter of Hart vTown Bd. of Town of Huntington, 114 AD3d at 683, quoting Infinity Consulting Group,Inc. v Town of Huntington, 49 AD3d at 814).
The petitioner further contends that the zone change at issue affected only the subjectproperty and, as such, constituted impermissible spot zoning. "Spot zoning is . . .the process of singling out a small parcel of land for a use classification totally different from thatof the surrounding area for the benefit of the owner of said property to the detriment of otherowners" (Matter of Rotterdam Ventures, Inc. v Town Bd. of the Town of Rotterdam, 90AD3d at 1362 [internal quotation marks omitted]). "In evaluating a claim of spot zoning, courtsmay consider several factors, including whether the rezoning is consistent with a comprehensiveland use plan, whether it is compatible with surrounding uses, the likelihood of harm tosurrounding properties, the availability and suitability of other parcels, and the recommendationsof professional planning staff" (id. [internal quotation marks omitted]; see Matter of Residents for ReasonableDev. v City of New York, 128 AD3d 609, 611 [2015]; Matter of Marcus v Board of Trustees ofVil. of Wesley Hills, 96 AD3d 1063, 1065-1066 [2012]).
Contrary to the petitioner's contention, the fact that the zone change at issue herein affectedonly the subject property does not, without more, make it impermissible spot zoning (seeMatter of Residents for Reasonable Dev. v City of New York, 128 AD3d at 611; Matterof Marcus v Board of Trustees of Vil. of Wesley Hills, 96 AD3d at 1065-1066).Furthermore, the zone change is not inconsistent with the Town's Comprehensive Plan and is"compatible with surrounding uses" (Matter of Rotterdam Ventures, Inc. v Town Bd. of theTown of Rotterdam, 90 AD3d at 1362 [internal quotation marks omitted]) and, on thisrecord, it cannot be said that the Town Board failed to weigh the competing interests of Scenicand the petitioner.
Town Law § 262 permits a Town to divide its unincorporated portions intozoning districts and impose regulations on those districts, but states that "[a]ll such regulationsshall be uniform for each class or kind of buildings, throughout such district but the regulationsin one district may differ from those in other districts." A Town's power to zone does not includethe power to "create a zoning ordinance that specifies the exact number and type of dwellingallowed," but only allows a Town to "determin[e] what may or may not be built" (BLF Assoc., LLC v Town ofHempstead, 59 AD3d 51, 55 [2008]). However, "a change in zoning may be subject toreasonable conditions and restrictions related to and incidental to the use of the property anddesigned to minimize any adverse impact on the surrounding area" (Cram v Town ofGeneva, 190 AD2d 1028, 1028-1029 [1993], citing Matter of St. Onge v Donovan,71 NY2d 507, 515-516 [1988]; seeMatter of Gentile v Village of Tuckahoe Zoning Bd. of Appeals, 87 AD3d 695, 696[2011]).
Here, the Comprehensive Plan stated that one of the objectives of the Town's goals was tocreate a diverse housing stock at a variety of prices in order to address the problem that manyfamilies could not afford to purchase or rent housing in the area, and that the creation ofmulti-family housing districts was one of the methods it would use to achieve this goal. Thus,contrary to the petitioner's contention, the imposition of a requirement to include a certainnumber or percentage of affordable housing units within a multi-family development wasconsistent with the Town's Comprehensive Plan and its overall zoning strategy. Furthermore, therequirement for the inclusion of affordable housing units is a "reasonable condition[ ]. . . related to and incidental to the use of the property" and, thus, is not in violationof Town Law § 262 (Cram v Town of Geneva, 190 AD2d at1028).
[*5] The petitioner's contention that the TownBoard's adoption of Local Law No. 1-2010 of the Town of Ramapo violated Municipal HomeRule Law §§ 20 (4) and (5) is not supported by the record (see Matter ofPete Drown, Inc. v Town Bd. of Town of Ellenburg, 188 AD2d 850, 852 [1992]; 41 KewGardens Rd. Assoc. v Tyburski, 124 AD2d 553 [1986]; see generally Matter of Village of Chestnut Ridge v Town of Ramapo,45 AD3d 74, 87 [2007]).
There is no merit to the respondents' contention that denial of final subdivision approval hasno effect upon preliminary site plan approval. By operation of law, denial of the respondents'final subdivision and site plan itself rescinded the preliminary approval (see Matter of Aloyav Planning Bd. of Town of Stony Point, 93 NY2d 334 [1999]).
The parties' remaining contentions are without merit.
Accordingly, the Supreme Court should have granted the petition and annulled the TownBoard's determination resolving to approve the findings statement pursuant to SEQRA for theproposed zoning change. In addition, since approval of the findings statement pursuant toSEQRA was required prior to amending the Comprehensive Plan or granting the proposedzoning change (see ECL 8-0109 [2]; 8-0105 [4] [i], [ii]; 6 NYCRR 617.4 [b] [1]-[3], [5];617.7 [a]), the annulment of the determination resolving to approve the findings statementpursuant to SEQRA requires the annulment of the determinations regarding the ComprehensivePlan and the proposed zoning change as well (see Matter of Land Master Montg I, LLC v Town of Montgomery, 54AD3d 408, 411 [2008]; Matter ofCity of Middletown v Town Bd. of Town of Wallkill, 54 AD3d 333, 337 [2008];Vitiello v City of Yonkers, 255 AD2d 506, 507 [1998]; 6 NYCRR 617.4 [b] [1]-[3], [5];617.7 [a]). We remit the matter to the Town Board for the preparation of a SupplementalEnvironmental Impact Statement on the issues of the environmental impact of placing theproposed development in close proximity to the existing Columbia Gas pipeline, and thecombined environmental impact of the pipeline and the development together (see Matter ofBronx Comm. for Toxic Free Schs. v New York City Sch. Constr. Auth., 20 NY3d at155-156). Leventhal, J.P., Austin, Cohen and Duffy, JJ., concur.